Differences between paid and unpaid social services for beneficiaries

Abstract

In many Western welfare states, social work services that have traditionally been provided by paid employees are being replaced by family support, community support, informal networks, and volunteering. For the field of social work, it is relevant to know what it matters to beneficiaries whether services are provided by volunteers or by paid employees. The central question of this article is therefore as follows: What are the differences between unpaid and paid social services for beneficiaries? The article is based on literature review and focus groups. Our results suggest that beneficiaries do experience some differences regarding the advantages of volunteer services for beneficiaries that can be summarized in three propositions: (1) services provided by volunteers are more relational than are services provided by paid employees, and they are therefore perceived as more equal, flexible and sincere. (2) The effects of volunteer services for beneficiaries are not exclusively positive. (3) Although particular tasks may appear to be interchangeable to some extent, the relative advantages of a given task depend upon whether it is performed by a paid worker or by a volunteer. Additional research is needed in order to provide further validation. SAMENVATTINGIn veel westerse verzorgingsstaten wordt sociale dienstverlening die tot voor kort werd uitgevoerd door beroepskrachten, vervangen door mantelzorg en vrijwilligerswerk. Voor het brede werkveld van het sociaal werk is het relevant om te weten wat deze verschuiving uitmaakt voor de gebruikers van

The Limits and Possibilities of Volunteering: A Framework for Explaining the Scope of Volunteer Involvement in Public and Nonprofit Organizations

“…Some research also recognizes that volunteers can perform certain tasks better than paid staff (and vice versa) (Brudney ; Hoogervorst et al ; Metz et al ). Volunteers may have time and capacity to provide extensive interaction or follow‐up to clients, generate a sense of empathy or concern for clientele on the part of the organization, or inspire support and confidence for the organization in the larger community.…”

Health outcomes associated with participating in community care centres for older people in Taiwan

“…First, although volunteers are usually enthusiastic, workers who get paid have a responsibility to get the work done, especially for those things they are told to do to keep their jobs. Higher accountability is also demanded of the paid staff in an organisation (Smith, 2017); second, paid staff usually receive more formal training to enhance performance (Metz, Roza, Meijs, van Baren, & Hoogervorst, 2017), and are therefore empowered to help outsiders such as recipients/clients or the larger community. It is also possible that the paid staff have greater ability and more accountability for performing better quality work.…”

Voluntary work in the Norwegian long-term care sector: complementing or substituting formal services?

“…This knowledge is essential for our understanding of the current role of volunteers in long-term care and to determine the extent to which the voluntary workforce is capable of aiding the formal care system in coming decades. These insights are also important to the social work profession, as recent research shows that it does make a difference to clients whether services are provided by volunteers or paid employees (Metz, Roza, Meijs, van Baren, & Hoogervorst, 2017).…”