Current Food Classifications in Epidemiological Studies Do Not Enable Solid Nutritional Recommendations for Preventing Diet-Related Chronic Diseases: The Impact of Food Processing

Abstract

To date, observational studies in nutrition have categorized foods into groups such as dairy, cereals, fruits, and vegetables. However, the strength of the association between food groups and chronic diseases is far from convincing. In most international expert surveys, risks are most commonly scored as probable, limited, or insufficient rather than convincing. In this position paper, we hypothesize that current food classifications based on botanical or animal origins can be improved to yield solid recommendations. We propose using a food classification that employs food processes to rank foods in epidemiological studies. Indeed, food health potential results from both nutrient density and food structure (i.e., the matrix effect), both of which can potentially be positively or negatively modified by processing. For example, cereal-based foods may be more or less refined, fractionated, and recombined with added salt, sugars, and fats, yielding a panoply of products with very different nutritional values. The same is true for other food groups. Finally, we propose that from a nutritional perspective, food processing will be an important issue to consider in the coming years, particularly in terms of strengthening the links between food and health and for proposing improved nutritional recommendations or actions. Adv Nutr 2015;6:629-38.

Highly Processed and Ready-to-Eat Packaged Food and Beverage Purchases Differ by Race/Ethnicity among US Households

“…To reduce these disparities, a better understanding of the types of foods purchased and consumed by each population group is needed to inform dietary guidance, interventions, or policy efforts (6)(7)(8). Scholars have proposed that future efforts may thus need a new focus on novel metrics, such as food processing (13)(14)(15)(16).…”

Sport Types and Time Spent Playing Sport Are Associated with Eating Pattern Among Young Brazilian Athletes

“…high in free sugars, unhealthy fats, and salt; and low in dietary fiber (14). Recent studies (27)(28)(29) processing to which the food was submitted, and also advocates for the restriction of foods and beverages with low nutritional value.…”

“…However, recent studies have increasingly been assessing the food consumption frequency and quality in adolescents and adults (12,13), and whether the foods are unprocessed, processed, or ultra-processed (14). This evidence is crucial, as nutrition-specific education programs should address both food choices and meals, and not just the required nutrients (10).…”

The effects of popular diets on type 2 diabetes management

“…In the last decades, nutritional science and recommendations have shifted from a specific nutrient amount or energy or calorie range to a broader view of overall nutritious lifestyle that emphasizes quality and dietary patterns that promote metabolic health . Instead of focusing on the amounts of single nutrients, the focus is on the interactions of the bioactive nonnutrients present in food (ie, fibre, antioxidants, and minerals) . As a result, the relationship between nutrition and health is viewed holistically and within the context of the whole diet.…”