Contributors to exchange structures and their effects on community solidarity in online communities

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to investigate which exchange structure, direct or generalized exchange, better promotes community solidarity in online communities (OCs). Furthermore, it examines the moderating effects of activity intensity on the relationship between exchange structure and community solidarity in order to resolve the conflicts in extant literature. Design/methodology/approach The research model is developed based on the social exchange theory (SET). It also accommodates social structures as determinants of exchange structure, such as organizational identity orientation (OIO) and distributive justice norms. Data in this study were collected from 376 OCs through an e-mail survey. Findings Generalized exchange has stronger effects on community solidarity than direct exchange. Furthermore, there was a significant difference in the impact on community solidarity between generalized exchange and direct exchange at high-activity intensity levels, whereas no significant differences were found at low-activity intensity conditions. OIO significantly influences exchange structure. Additionally, equality norm significantly influences generalized exchange, whereas need norm significantly influences direct exchange. Originality/value In information systems research, there have not been any attempts to identify the determinants of exchange structure in OCs. Furthermore, only a couple of studies have empirically investigated the relationship between exchange structure and OC solidarity, and yet they found conflicting results. This research makes contributions to an enhancement of theoretical precision of the SET in two ways: by empirically examining the determinants of exchange structure, and by introducing a third variable, activity intensity, as a moderator of the relationship between exchange structure and OC solidarity.

Effects of member similarity on group norm conformity, group identity and social participation in the context of social networking sites

“…According to social exchange theory, the exchange of resources results in the creation of group activities; this occurs on the basis of the concepts of equality and reciprocity (Han et al, 2019). Resources are of two types: material and nonmaterial (Yu et al, 2015).…”

The more the merrier? The effects of system-aggregated group size information on user's efficacy and intention to participate in collective actions

“…Collective efficacy and self-efficacy in networked collective actions When faced with large amounts of competing information, individuals often look for heuristic cues to simplify their decision-making process (Chaiken and Maheswaran, 1994;Tversky and Kahneman, 1974). Studies have shown that individuals are prone to select information that confirms their beliefs and makes them feel good and identify with groups that are similar to themselves (Frey, 1986;Garrett, 2009;Knobloch-Westerwick and Meng, 2009;Han et al, 2019). However, beliefs and group identifications alone are not sufficient to drive participation in collective action.…”