Configurational Entropy Revisited

Abstract

Entropy change is categorized in some prominent general chemistry textbooks as being either positional (configurational) or thermal. In those texts, the accompanying emphasis on the dispersal of matter—independent of energy considerations and thus in discord with kinetic molecular theory—is most troubling. This article shows that the variants of entropy can be treated from a unified viewpoint and argues that to decrease students' confusion about the nature of entropy change these variants of entropy should be merged. Molecular energy dispersal in space is implicit but unfortunately tacit in the cell models of statistical mechanics that develop the configurational entropy change in gas expansion, fluids mixing, or the addition of a non-volatile solute to a solvent. Two factors are necessary for entropy change in chemistry. An increase in thermodynamic entropy is enabled in a process by the motional energy of molecules (that, in chemical reactions, can arise from the energy released from a bond energy change). However, entropy increase is only actualized if the process results in a larger number of arrangements for the system's energy, that is, a final state that involves the most probable distribution for that energy under the new constraints. Positional entropy should be eliminated from general chemistry instruction and, especially benefiting "concrete minded" students, it should be replaced by emphasis on the motional energy of molecules as enabling entropy change.

Good Use of a ‘Bad’ Metaphor

“…& The disorder metaphor emphasises spatial configuration of the constituent particles of a system, but tends to neglect the role of energy (Lambert 2002b(Lambert , 2007Alonso and Finn 1995;Brosseau and Viard 1992). & The messy room analogy and other examples, such as a particular poker hand, give a single snapshot view, rather than showing the large number of microstates, i.e.…”

Métodos semiempíricos de química quântica no ensino da entalpia das reações químicas

“…A segunda lei analisa a espontaneidade das transformações e explica por que algumas reações ocorrem espontaneamente, enquanto outras não. A espontaneidade de uma reação tende a crescer com o aumento da entropia (S), a qual é tratada como uma medida da maior dispersão de energia de um sistema (ou sistema mais vizinhanças) [16]. A variação de entropia de um sistema pode ser calculada pela equação 2.…”

Non-extensive thermostatistics approach to metal melting entropy

“…Differently, thermodynamic entropy is defined through the relation dS = δQ/T where δQ is the infinitesimal heat exchanged by the system with its environment at temperature T . However, it is strongly believed that configurational entropy and thermodynamical entropy should represent ultimately the same physical quantity in spite of their different expression [21]. Differently, in the non-extensive formalism, the equivalence between the configurational entropy and thermodynamical entropy is still an open question.…”