Comparing Candidate Selection: A Feminist Institutionalist Approach

Abstract

This contribution evaluates the theoretical and methodological challenges of researching the gendered dynamics of candidate selection in comparative perspective. It argues that comparative studies should take into account not only the gendered nature of political parties and their wider institutional context, but must also investigate the informal aspects of the selection process and their gendered consequences. The article explores these dynamics by revisiting original in-depth research on the candidate selection process in two different settings -Thailand and Scotland. Using a common analytical framework, the article reflects on this work and points to two key aspects of the interaction between formal and informal rules -the gendered consequences of informal party recruitment and of local influence over candidate selection -which are critically important for understanding the continuity of male political dominance and female under-representation. The article concludes by outlining a research agenda for comparative work on gender, institutions and candidate selection and pointing to future directions for work in this area.Keywords: candidate selection, gender, feminist institutionalism, political parties, informal institutions Investigating the gendered and institutional dimensions of the opportunity structures within political parties is essential in order to explain women's chronic minority status in politics as well as the persistence of male dominance. The small but growing body of work on gender, political parties and candidate selection has contributed many important insights about the

The gender politics of executive candidate selection and reselection

“…As posited by Duerst-Lahti (1997: 12), 'understanding the implications of gender is essential for understanding executive power' . The relational character of gender entails that women's chances of being (s)elected are not independent from men's chances of being (s)elected (Bjarnegård & Kenny 2016). Attention must be then paid to the extent to which access to opportunities and the definition of the qualities more valued to take advantage of those opportunities are patterned through gender (Kenney 1996: 456).…”

Corruption and women in cabinets: Informal barriers to recruitment in the executive

“…Since women and other candidates from out‐groups tend to lack such contacts, the existence of close‐knit networks often benefits candidates that are within the dominant group (Bjarnegård, , p. 37). For example, close relationships between two men are seen as stabilizing, whereas close relationships between a man and a woman are seen as endangering the predictability and stability of these ties (Bjarnegård & Kenny, ). Arriola and Johnson () advance a similar argument about clientelism in the African context.…”

The Women Representation Policy and its Effect to Women Political Participation in Jember, Indonesia

“…Despite this, the attempt of every political party to comply with the policy deserves appreciation. Their compliance to the policy is indicated in the increase of women representatives, that it is against the findings by Bjarnegard, stating that the regulation is incapable of increasing the elected women representatives (Bjarnegard & Kenny, 2016). But who made the decision, whose determine someone to be a candidate is hard to know because it is in a secret garden (Bjarnegard & Kenny, 2015).…”

“…That the societal culture is hard to change, Paxton in his study mentions one possible thing to be done, which is to make the policy more effective through changes in the norms that rule the women participation in politics (Paxton, 2015). This statement, however, has been argued by Bjarnegard by stating that activating regulations would only make the political parties better at implementing the letter of the law, and they do not get more women elected (Bjarnegard, 2016).…”