Civic education stuck in a quagmire: A critical review of civic education in Hong Kong?

Abstract

Civic education is considered as a way to nurture good citizens who work to develop the polity. However, in real politics, education often mirrors instead of shaping the political development. Reviewing civic education of Hong Kong from a historical development perspective, this article explains that civic education has for long been used a tool of governance by the political regimes. This was true not only during the days of colonial rule but is also that after the reversion of sovereignty in 1997. Manipulating civic education as a tool of governance can have far-reaching consequence. In the case of Hong Kong's civic education, the problems due to neglect, deliberate suppression, and twisting around in different historical phases created the problem for the future. Hong Kong's civic education is now stuck in a quagmire, and preparing young people to face the sociopolitical challenges becomes increasingly difficult. Finally, this article makes suggestions for reforming civic education in Hong Kong. To conduct this study, a mixed methodology was adopted which comprised both literature review and qualitative interviews with civic education teachers and teachers of the subject Liberal Studies. Selective discourses of the teachers are reported to inform the understanding of the discussion.

Effects of computer-aided and blended teaching strategies on students’ achievement in civic education concepts in mountain learning ecologies

“…Edwards and Usher (2008) pointed out that these four dimensions could only serve as technical devices for educational systems monitoring, while providing emerging areas of visualization cum circulation of knowledge about civic competence, especially its learning and teaching. Unlike many developing nations where civic education has been manipulated to serve the interests of different ruling elites (Yuen 2016), the civic education programme formerly taught as 'civics' during the colonial era in Nigeria (Falade and Adeyemi 2015), got re-introduced into the Nigerian school system in 2007 consequent on persistent cries of scholars that it is an instrument that could be used to re-engineer effective citizenship traits among youths in Nigeria (Adesina and Adeyemi 2007). The government policy document however described the new civic education programme as a 'sub-set' of the existing social studies programme, with the social studies teachers in Nigeria mandated to teach the subject (NERDC 2007a, b).…”

Reformulating Civic Education as Political Education in Indonesia in the Convergence Era

“…The formulation of political education in Citizenship Education in Indonesia can be done through the material mapping that can provide space in the partisan political phenomena. Citizenship education is considered to be the way to nurture good citizens who work to develop governance [35].…”

“…Recent research on Citizenship and Ethical Education (CEE) in Ethiopia reveals the need for improvements in some fields related to the current CEE curriculum [34]. Civic Education is considered as a way to get citizen's participation in government [35]. It must have a goal to be able to contribute knowledge about politics to students [36].…”

Understanding civic education in Hong Kong: a Bernsteinian approach

“…In light of the anticipated return to Chinese sovereignty following the signing of the Sino-British Joint Declaration in 1984, civic education was oriented towards greater inclusion of China-related elements to facilitate students' acquaintance with traditional Chinese culture and China's socio-political development (Tse, 2007). Shortly after the 1997 handover, the Chinese government endeavoured to strengthen the national identity among Hong Kong residents through promoting national education (Yuen, 2016); however, such efforts were met with resistance owing to the strong presence of the local identity which prides itself on the city's cosmopolitan outlook while it maintains a certain psychological distance from the political elements of China (Chong, 2018). The heightened sense of local identity is reflected in civic education, with scholarly studies conducted by Fairbrother (2005) and Kennedy (2010) noting a marked increase of civic awareness among students, especially in the espousal of rule of law, democracy, and human rights as the core values of Hong Kong society.…”