City mouse, country mouse: a mixed-methods evaluation of perceived communication barriers between rural family physicians and urban consultants in Newfoundland and Labrador, Canada

Abstract

ObjectivesTo examine perceived communication barriers between urban consultants and rural family physicians practising routine and emergency care in remote subarctic Newfoundland and Labrador (NL).DesignThis study used a mixed-methods design. Quantitative and qualitative data were collected through exploratory surveys, comprised of closed and open-ended questions. The quantitative data was analysed using comparative statistical analyses, and a thematic analysis was applied to the qualitative data.Participants52 self-identified rural family physicians and 23 urban consultants were recruited via email. Rural participants were also recruited at the Family Medicine Rural Preceptor meetings in St John's, NL.SettingRural family physicians and urban consultants in NL completed a survey assessing perceived barriers to effective communication.ResultsData confirmed that both groups perceived communication difficulties with one another; with 23.1% rural and 27.8% urban, rating the difficulties as frequent (p=0.935); 71.2% rural and 72.2% urban as sometimes (p=0.825); 5.8% rural and 0% urban acknowledged never perceiving difficulties (p=0.714). Overall, 87.1% of participants indicated that perceived communication difficulties impacted patient care. Primary trends that emerged as perceived barriers for rural physicians were time constraints and misunderstanding of site limitations. Urban consultants' perceived barriers were inadequate patient information and lack of native language skills.ConclusionsBarriers to effective communication are perceived between rural family physicians and urban consultants in NL.

Factors associated with patient rating of physician communication effectiveness and satisfaction in musculoskeletal care

“…There is evidence that clinician gender, ethnicity, and specialty and patient language and race affect satisfaction. 13,14 One might expect communication effectiveness to increase with return visits because the patient-clinician relationship is better established, but we didn't find such a relationship. Another limitation was that the order of questionnaire completion was not randomized.…”

Prehospital Trauma Care: A Simulation Scenario for Rural-Based Healthcare Providers

“…Our scenario also places an emphasis on communication, as deficiencies here can significantly impact care [11,12]. Firstly, for learners working in rural and remote regions, the practice of closed-loop communication throughout the simulation, as well as the handover of patients, are crucial skills to obtain in clinical practice.…”

“…Finally, miscommunication between rural physicians and their urban-based colleagues can compromise trauma care [11,12], causing significant delays in transport and the onset of care. This may in turn increase mortality for rural trauma patients.…”

Automated Inflating Resuscitator (AIR): Design and Development of a 3D-Printed Ventilator Prototype and Corresponding Simulation Scenario Based on the Management of a Critical COVID-19 Patient

“…4. Communication: Communication is an important component in patient outcomes, and high-fidelity simulations have been identified as a method of promoting communication skills relevant to emergency procedures [ 15 , 16 ]. Training scenarios should therefore emphasize communication between and within healthcare teams.…”