Cities and Wealth in the South Atlantic: Buenos Aires and Rio de Janeiro before 1860

Abstract

Rio de Janeiro and Buenos Aires, the leading cities of the South Atlantic, experienced substantial growth in wealth holding during the first half of the nineteenth century. In this article, we argue that this growth is best interpreted in a broad, comparative framework, which examines these cities in relation to their internal demographic and institutional arrangements and to their external links to the Atlantic World. Our research emphasizes three major comparative findings. First, according to our samples, both Rio de Janeiro and Buenos Aires experienced substantial growth in wealth holding from the 1820s through the 1850s, well before their participation in the better-known global economic expansion of the late nineteenth century. Second, residents of both South Atlantic cities held wealth broadly similar in scale with their counterparts in comparable cities in North America. And third, wealth inequality was probably no greater in Rio de Janeiro and Buenos Aires than in contemporary cities in the United States. Moreover, we believe that these increases in average wealth holding, as well as changes in the allocation of wealth across sectors, suggests economies that were growing rapidly while becoming more complex. In order to arrive at these findings we synthesized a growing new literature on the economic dynamism of the early nineteenth century in southeastern

Five Centuries of Latin American Inequality

“…He is not able to report any colonial observations. See also Johnson and Frank (2006) and Gelman and Santilli (2006).…”

Life on the Edge: Elites, Wealth and Inequality in Sonora 1871-1910

“…Given that statistical records to estimate inequality before modern reporting started in 1989 with the ENIGH, we follow the strategy pioneered by Lindert (1981) and Lindert and Williamson (1983) to convert administrative proxies such as wills and probates into comparable units for the contemporary population 1 . The use of administrative data, from tax records to wills and probates has been in popular use in the study of inequality over recent decades, for example in Kicza (1982) and Chowning (1999), the ground-breaking study by Johnson and Frank (2006), and more recently Piketty (2014), Lindert and Williamson (2016) and Alvaredo et al (2018).…”

History without Evidence: Latin American Inequality since 1491

“…He is not able to report any colonial observations. See also Johnson and Frank (2006) and Gelman and Santilli (2006). Europe (52.9), not higher.…”