Challenging the Moral Status of Blood Donation

Abstract

The World Health Organisation encourages that blood donation becomes voluntary and unremunerated, a system already operated in the UK. Drawing on public documents and videos, this paper argues that blood donation is regarded and presented as altruistic and supererogatory. In advertisements, donation is presented as something undertaken for the benefit of others, a matter attracting considerable gratitude from recipients and the collecting organisation. It is argued that regarding blood donation as an act of supererogation is wrongheaded, and an alternative account of blood donation as moral obligation is presented. Two arguments are offered in support of this position. First, the principle of beneficence, understood in a broad consequentialist framework obliges donation where the benefit to the recipient is large and the cost to the donor relatively small. This argument can be applied, with differing levels of normativity, to various acts of donation. Second, the wrongness of free riding requires individuals to contribute to collective systems from which they benefit. Alone and in combination these arguments present moral reasons for donation, recognised in communication strategies elsewhere. Research is required to evaluate the potential effects on donation of a campaign which presents blood donation as moral obligation, but of wider importance is the recognition that other-regarding considerations in relation to our own as well as others' health result in a range not only of choices but also of obligations.

Expectations and Decisions in the Volunteer’s Dilemma: Effects of Social Distance and Social Projection

“…Research has shown that many individuals cooperate on the condition that there is evidence or a good expectation that the other person will also cooperate (Gintis, 2000; Fischbacher et al, 2001; Nielsen et al, 2014). …”

A Doação na Literatura Científica Nacional: Contribuições à Psicologia Moral

“…De fato, a análise realizada no presente trabalho identificou a gratidão como central às questões de doação. Isso se confirma em estudos recentes sobre as distintas nuanças da gratidão manifestadas por doadores e receptores na doação de órgãos (O'Brien, Donaghue, Walker, & Wood, 2014), embriões (Scully, Haimes, Mitzkat, Porz, & Rehmann-Sutter, 2012) ou sangue (Snelling, 2014).…”

The metaethics of nursing codes of ethics and conduct

“…It might include the fixed smile and palpably false wish that a customer 'have a nice day' (Wang, 2016) but also acts similar to that performed by Simone's replacement. Although, unlike a compassionate act, a kind act might not be driven by desire (Phillips & Taylor, 2009) or virtue there is 22 In a similar vein, it has been argued that blood donation, considered and presented as supererogatory, should rather be considered as obligatory (Snelling, 2014). 23 Use of the word (in) appropriate also shows this circularity.…”