Breathing and Singing: Objective Characterization of Breathing Patterns in Classical Singers

Abstract

Singing involves distinct respiratory kinematics (i.e. movements of rib cage and abdomen) to quiet breathing because of different demands on the respiratory system. Professional classical singers often advocate for the advantages of an active control of the abdomen on singing performance. This is presumed to prevent shortening of the diaphragm, elevate the rib cage, and thus promote efficient generation of subglottal pressure during phonation. However, few studies have investigated these patterns quantitatively and inter-subject variability has hindered the identification of stereotypical patterns of respiratory kinematics. Here, seven professional classical singers and four untrained individuals were assessed during quiet breathing, and when singing both a standard song and a piece of choice. Several parameters were extracted from respiratory kinematics and airflow, and principal component analysis was used to identify typical patterns of respiratory kinematics. No group differences were observed during quiet breathing. During singing, both groups adapted to rhythmical constraints with decreased time of inspiration and increased peak airflow. In contrast to untrained individuals, classical singers used greater percentage of abdominal contribution to lung volume during singing and greater asynchrony between movements of rib cage and abdomen. Classical singers substantially altered the coordination of rib cage and abdomen during singing from that used for quiet breathing. Despite variations between participants, principal component analysis revealed consistent pre-phonatory inward movements of the abdominal wall during singing. This contrasted with untrained individuals, who demonstrated synchronous respiratory movements during all tasks. The inward abdominal movements observed in classical singers elevates intra-abdominal pressure and may increase the length and the pressure-generating capacity of rib cage expiratory muscles for potential improvements in voice quality.

Myth busted? Challenging what we think we know about charismatic speech

“…Bottom line: The myth that belly breathing and an upright posture support speaker charisma is busted. It is true that belly breathing has a favorable effect on voice quality, which is also consistent with studies on singing and speech pathology (Salomoni & van den Hoorn, 2016;Thorpe et al, 2001;Xu et al, 1991). However, this favorable effect does not include those acoustic-prosodic parameters that listeners use when rating speaker charisma.…”

Superagudos: análise perceptivo-auditiva da voz e autorrelato em sopranos profissionais

“…Given that this question did not direct the soprano's perception towards any particular part of her body, it allowed her to reflect freely and respond as she considered relevant. This convergence of sensations among the singers indicates a common axis of respiratory support in the emission of upper high notes and, indeed, in all vocal emission (18) . Although some authors do consider the classiacl singer not capable of describing his or her physical sensations during singing (19) , the sopranos in their self-report referred to concrete elements during the emission of upper high notes.…”

Aerosol transmission of COVID-19 and infection risk in indoor environments

“…This respiratory rate is higher than of trained but lower than of untrained singers. 71 We can compare with an actual COVID-19 infection event during a choir rehearsal in the state of Washington in the USA on 10 March 2020, for which conditions are well-documented. 38 Our algorithm reproduces the observed very high infection rate (>80%) for a super infectious subject in the room and a breathing/vocalization ratio of about 0.3, very close to the algorithm settings applied here.…”

“…This respiratory rate is higher than of trained but lower than of untrained singers. 71 We can compare with an actual COVID-19 infection event during a choir rehearsal in the state of Washington in the USA on 10…”