AR Feels “Softer” than VR: Haptic Perception of Stiffness in Augmented versus Virtual Reality

Abstract

Does it feel the same when you touch an object in Augmented Reality (AR) or in Virtual Reality (VR)? In this paper we study and compare the haptic perception of stiffness of a virtual object in two situations: (1) a purely virtual environment versus (2) a real and augmented environment. We have designed an experimental setup based on a Microsoft HoloLens and a haptic force-feedback device, enabling to press a virtual piston, and compare its stiffness successively in either Augmented Reality (the virtual piston is surrounded by several real objects all located inside a cardboard box) or in Virtual Reality (the same virtual piston is displayed in a fully virtual scene composed of the same other objects). We have conducted a psychophysical experiment with 12 participants. Our results show a surprising bias in perception between the two conditions. The virtual piston is on average perceived stiffer in the VR condition compared to the AR condition. For instance, when the piston had the same stiffness in AR and VR, participants would select the VR piston as the stiffer one in 60% of cases. This suggests a psychological effect as if objects in AR would feel "softer" than in pure VR. Taken together, our results open new perspectives on perception in AR versus VR, and pave the way to future studies aiming at characterizing potential perceptual biases.

Serum BDNF’s Role as a Biomarker for Motor Training in the Context of AR-Based Rehabilitation after Ischemic Stroke

“…To stimulate the motor cortex, we chose a method of influencing sensory systems using biological feedback. Sensory cortex stimulation was performed using augmented reality, which is good in terms of patient safety [ 29 ]. We created a controlled virtual environment that visualizes sensory stimuli, the characteristics of which depend on the parameters of human movement.…”

Performance IEEE 802.14.5 and zigbee protocol on realtime monitoring augmented reality based wireless sensor network system

“…90-97 In the future, monitoring data technology is very important besides transmission media. There are more technologies can monitor much data as using web pages, the Android application or using augmented reality [17]- [20]. Augmented reality is a technology that will bring digital content to real world using camera and latches called marker.…”

“…Many developments have been done to make augmented reality easy to use and maximize to work [19]. Nowadays, there are many AR glasses which were known in the market like Hololens by Microsoft, and META by meta corp [17]. This is a sign which means augmented reality will be implemented in a various sector in the future including IoT technology [18], [21].…”

“…al. [17] have been designed an experimental setup based on a Microsoft HoloLens and a haptic force-feedback device. They are enabling them for pressing a virtual piston, and make stiffness successively comparation with either Augmented Reality.…”

A Quality of Experience assessment of haptic and augmented reality feedback modalities in a gait analysis system

“…Haptic feedback has been studied in many works related to human activities [20], motor learning [21], and gait retraining [22]. Numerous works have compared haptic feedback with other modalities and have reported haptic: to be "less intrusive" than virtual reality feedback [23]; to be better in supporting task performance when compared to visual feedback for lower extremities [24] in gait; not to affect ecological validity of interaction compared with other modalities [25]. In addition, Haptic has been reported as easier to understand and follow when compared to auditory and visual stimuli [26].…”