Application of MCDM and BIM for Evaluation of Asset Redevelopment Solutions

Abstract

Abstract:The current paper analyses the application of Multiple Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) and Building Information Modelling (BIM) techniques for integrated information management when assessing redevelopment solutions of former industrial buildings with emphasis on sustainable development. The theoretical approach of complex decisionmaking model for asset redevelopment is proposed and practical case study of old equipment factory redevelopment is presented. Sixteen criteria combined in three groups as economic, environmental and technological indicators are analysed both with ranking of possible redevelopment alternatives of the building using Weighted Aggregated Sum Product Assessment method with grey attributes scores (WASPAS-G). The selection of the most rational redevelopment solution for analysed projects is also supported by BIM techniques and allows implementation of whole project life-cycle management strategy in real life.Keywords: information management, sustainable asset redevelopment, MCDM, WASPAS-G, BIM, building life cycle. 293useful for handling numerous information and for decision support [11,28,29]. Uncertainty of information and risk level are the largest in the beginning of construction project, while their influence decline to an acceptable level in the elaboration of the information in the course of the project, i.e. adjusting the data over the entire building lifecycle. Therefore, the most important is to manage and control the information at the beginning of a project and to select the most effective solution.Accordingly, the aim of the current research is to suggest application of MCDM and BIM techniques for integrated information management, when selecting and implementing the most effective sustainable asset redevelopment solution. Integrated decisionmaking model, emphasizing interconnections between the techniques, is presented in Chapter 2. Due to high level of uncertainty, using Weighted Aggregated Sum Product Assessment method with grey numbers is suggested. A case study of abandoned industrial building redevelopment, involving 3D modelling and multiple criteria evaluation, is presented in Chapter 3.The outcomes of the study revealed that the suggested information management and decision-making model is a reliable technique for project selection and management in uncertain environment. The objectives of the study were effectively attained by determining the priority order of the analysed asset redevelopment solutions and making it possible to implement the selected project using Digital Construction techniques. Methodology for Evaluation of Asset Redevelopment Solutions Asset management decision-making using MCDM and BIM techniquesThis specific subtopic of the implementation of new Digital Construction techniques (like geospatial GIS, 3D Laser Scan and BIM) was found as new research field partially analysed in some scientific works [1,15]. The best practice, knowledge, experience and "knowhow" [26,27] leads world to new approach of connecting traditional survey methods with ...

Analysis of BIM Methodology Application for Masonry Facade Constructions

“…Siekiant išvengti šių problemų ir jų padarinių, būtina suderinti ir palaikyti nuolatinius informacijos mainus tarp dalyvių, įgyvendinančių statybos projektą, nes projekto įgyvendi-nimo pradžioje ir laiku priimti projektiniai sprendimai yra ekonomiški ir efektyvesni (Migilinskas 2012;Pavlovskis et al 2016).…”

“…), nes BIM sumažina riziką, suteikia geresnę ir tikslesnę informaciją visame kūrimo procese, užtikrina mažesnes užsakovo išlaidas (Pavlovskis et al 2016). Visa tai lemia bendro grafinio modelio kūrimas (angl.…”

An Analysis of Integrated Project Delivery Method in Inplementation of Public Projects

“…Užsakovas gali siekti maksimaliai išsaugoti vertę tik suprasdamas informacijos svarbą. Technologijų tiekėjai parenka produktus, mažinan-čius prarandamą laiką ir medžiagų sąnaudas, išlaidas ir didinančius efektyvumą visose projektavimo, gamybos, statybų ir palaikymo fazėse (Pavlovskis et al 2016). 537 bei išdiskutuoti visas projekto sąlygas.…”

“…Nebenaudojami popieriniai brėžiniai ir visa kita 2D informacija, o dirbama su 3D projekto modeliu. Tai reiš-kia, kad statinio koncepcijos kūrimo etape dalyvauja ne tik architektas, bet ir visų inžinerinių sistemų projektuotojai, statybos specialistai ir licencijuoti darnios plėtros konsultantai (Pavlovskis et al 2016). Tai leidžia matyti pakeitimus, laiku atlikti būtinus skaičiavimus ir analizes, rasti finansiškai racionaliausius sprendimus, išvengti klaidų, 1 pav.…”

Initial data preparation for 3D modelling of heritage building

“…Research methods and tools -initial data collection by historical drawing analysis, manual measurement, photogrammetry methods, and "As-Built" 3D model creation. The results of the current case study were analyzed as well as compared with the similar studies in the scientific literature (Pavlovskis, Antuchevičienė, & Migilinskas, 2016;D'Amico & Currà, 2017;Bruno & Roncella, 2018). The SWOT analysis identified initial data preparation and 3D model development strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats.…”