“…Tensions remain among "natural protectionists" strongly advocating a "people-free" protected areas (PAs) approach (e.g., Oates, 2006;Terborgh, 1999;Terborgh & Peres, 2017), and "social conservationists" supporting various forms of sustainable use, with associated elements of poverty alleviation and social justice (e.g., Brechin, Wilshusen, Fortwangler, & West, 2003;Brockington, Duffy, & Igoe, 2010;West, Igoe, & Brockington, 2006). Furthermore, a substantial proportion of the world's biodiversity remains outside conservation enclosures (see Jones et al, 2018), or is largely aligned with Indigenous territories (e.g., Garnett et al, 2018;Gullison & Hardner, 2018;Schuster, Germain, Bennett, Reo, & Arcese, 2019). However, as Brechin et al (2003) have noted efforts to protect nature are also very much a "social enterprise."…”