“Women fear the law more than abusers”: a study of public trust in health and legal response to violence against women in Santo André, São Paulo State, Brazil

Abstract

Little is known about how perceptions of government affects women’s views of violence against women. This qualitative study examines women’s perceptions of violence against women laws and trust in the health and legal sector response in São Paulo State, Brazil. Thirty interviews with female residents of Santo André, 18 years and older, were audio recorded, transcribed, coded, and analyzed for themes using MAXQDA12 software. All women were familiar with at least one federal violence against women law. They expressed widespread lack of trust in the government. They viewed the legal sector as ineffective and felt violence against women laws have little impact, or exacerbate violence. Disdain for the health sector was less prominent than for the legal sector. A generalized lack of trust in government manifests as a lack of confidence in these laws for women seeking support through legal and health sectors. Adoption of legal protections for women is a significant accomplishment. However, health and legal sector violence against women response needs to consider perceptions of government, how violence against women laws are operationalized, and the role of each sector in ensuring women’s safety. Violence against women response efforts should include standardized intersectoral procedures including referral to accessible resources and means of screening women who may be at high risk for femicide.

A Case Study of Domestic Violence Arrests during the COVID-19 Pandemic in Miami-Dade County

“…As well, practitioners, advocates, and policymakers should embrace the role of technology in helping provide assistance and services to domestic violence survivors including, for example, the myPlan app, which provides resources for various relationship issues and concerns (see Glass et al, 2021). Finally, on a societal level, policymakers and politicians could do more to help increase trust in government and the legal system among domestic violence survivors (Evans et al, 2020).…”

Prevalence of Physical Violence Against Brazilian Women: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

“…Broader public policies are needed, aimed at preventing violence against women, including education, justice, public safety, work, and social security, among others. Health services play an important role and are more trusted by Brazilian women than the legal system and may represent the victim’s first contact with public institutions (Evans et al, 2020). Strengthen the Brazilian Unified Health System is also necessary to welcome the victims and guide them in the steps to overcome violence, in addition to provide health care assistance (Minayo et al, 2018).…”

Carga doméstica, cuidado de los dependientes y violencia en el hogar durante el confinamiento por la Covid-19

“…Asimismo, García (10) en su investigación mediante un sistema interactivo monitoreó la asignación de las tareas en casa en los miembros de la familia, y encontró que, las mujeres aún asumen mayores roles tradicionales, siendo que esto fue aprendido en la infancia y se mantuvo a pesar de tener ella otros trabajos fuera de casa. (5,11) Con relación al tema de la violencia doméstica, situación compleja en pandemia, en la medida de la desconfianza y sentimiento de desprotección por parte de las mujeres afectadas por la violencia hacia sus autoridades (12) ; y sumado a ello, el cierre de los establecimientos de atención durante la pandemia, lo que generó una obvia disminución de las notificaciones o reportes de la violencia (13) . Como antecedente, en el año 2020 en el Perú la violencia contra las mujeres alguna vez en su vida fue sufrida por 1 de cada 2 mujeres; siendo la violencia psicológica la más frecuente.…”