Validity of questions about activities of daily living to screen for dependency in older adults

Abstract

OBJECTIVE To determine the criterion validity of the activities of daily living present in functionality questionnaires in older adults for population surveys and to identify which activities are valid to quantify the real daily need for help of this population.METHODS This is a population sample of older adults stratified by levels of functionality, according to self-perception of dependency in the activities of daily living. Self-perception was compared with the gold standard – direct observation of these activities in the household of older adults by a trained professional, blinded to the answers in the questionnaire. At the visit, it was decided if the older adult needed help to perform any of the activities of daily living for the research. The sensitivity of each activity of daily living was greater when the self-assessment that there was no need for help coincided with the assessment of the professional. Specificity indicates coincidence regarding the need for help in the activities of daily living – coefficients of sensitivity and specificity above 70% were considered as indicative of good validity.RESULTS Self-assessments showed better sensitivity than specificity – older adults and observers agreed more on daily independency than on dependency. All activities showed sensitivity above 70%. Some activities had low (go shopping: 55%) or very low specificity (brush the hair: 33%). The best specificities were to take a shower and dress up (95.8% for both), among the personal ones, and to use transportation and perform banking transactions (78% for both), among the instrumental ones.CONCLUSIONS Activities of daily living can be valid indicators of functional dependence. The best coefficients of validity were generally obtained for personal activities. Some activities with good sensitivities and specificities – walk 100 meters, take a shower, and lie down in and get out of the bed – can be used to classify older adults into low, average, and high need for help depending on the affected activities and, therefore, can help in the planning of health services aimed at them.

Disability on performing daily living activities in the elderly and history of falls: an analysis of the National Health Survey, 2013

“…BADL refers to the capacity to selfcare, specifically the ability to dress, take a bath, transfer, feed, go to the bathroom, and have urinary and fecal continence. IADL is related to the functional capacity of managing the environment in which they live and socially interact, such as using a transport, using the telephone, preparing meals, washing clothes, handling money, administering medicines, and shopping [11][12][13][14] .…”

Walking speed and home adaptations are associated with independence after stroke: a population-based prevalence study

“…A proxy was invited when participants were unable to answer the questions. Those measurement procedures have been widely used in epidemiological studies 14 and all activities showed sensibility higher than 85% with the observation of health-professionals 15 . The participants were asked to rate their performance on each activity using a Likert scale (1 = no difficulty, 2 = little difficulty, 3 = great difficulty or 4 = unable to perform).…”

Factors that determine dependence in daily activities: A cross-sectional study of family practice non-attenders from Slovenia

“…There were several potential limitations to our study. We used our tool with eight different categories and calculated a total score [ 41 , 42 ]. Another limitation is the cross-sectional design, which does not enable the detection of causal relations between variables.…”