Two-pion-exchange and other higher-order contributions to the pp → ppπ 0 reaction Y. Kim (a,b) , T. Sato (c) , F. Myhrer (a) and K. Kubodera
AbstractMuch effort has been invested on effective-field-theoretical studies of the near-threshold N N→N N π reactions and, in order to deal with the somewhat large three-momentum transfers involved, the momentum counting scheme (MCS) was proposed as an alternative to the usual Weinberg counting scheme. Given the fact that a quantitative explanation of the existing high-precision N N → N N π data requires a careful examination of higher chiral order contributions to the transition operator, we make a detailed numerical investigation of the convergence property of MCS for a pilot case of the pp → ppπ 0 reaction. Our study indicates that MCS is superior to the Weinberg scheme in identifying dominant higher order contributions to the N N→N N π reactions.There exists a substantial accumulation of high-precision data on various observables for the near-threshold NN →NNπ reactions, e.g. [1], and providing a coherent understanding of these experimental results has been a prominent theoretical challenge, see e.g., [2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9]. Heavy-baryon chiral perturbation theory (HBχPT), which is a low-energy effective field theory of QCD, is expected to offer a systematic framework for describing these reactions. In HBχPT, the four-momentum Q characterizing a given physical process is assumed to be small compared to the chiral scale Λ χ ≃ 4πf π ≃ 1 GeV, and contributions to the transition amplitude are classified according to the power (chiral order) of the expansion parameter ǫ ≡ Q/Λ χ .
1The coefficients of possible terms in the HBχPT Lagrangian, called low-energy constants (LECs), can in principle be linked to the matrix elements of QCD operators but in practice they are determined from experimental observables. Once all the LEC are fixed up to a specified chiral order, HBχPT allows us to make predictions for a wide range of hadronic and electroweak processes.Although, as mentioned, HBχPT presupposes the smallness of its expansion parameter Q/Λ χ , the pion production reactions involve somewhat large momentum transfers, p ≃ √ m π m N , even at threshold. This implies that the application ofHBχPT to the NN → NNπ reactions may involve some delicate aspects, but this also means that these processes may serve as a good test case for probing the applicability (or the limit of applicability) of HBχPT. It is worth emphasizing that finding a valid EFT expansion scheme for the NN → NNπ reactions is of general importance (going beyond the specific context of the NN→NNπ reactions) because, once such a scheme is found, we expect to be able to develop similar frameworks for other nuclear processes which involve rather large energy-momentum transfers and hence may not be quite amenable to the straightforward application of the ordinary HBχPT approach. To account for the rather large momentum transfers involved in the NN →NNπ reactions, Cohen, Friar, Miller and van Kolck [5] proposed to r...