No abstract

In dogs, resection of a length of the ulna equal to twice the diameter of the mid-shaft leaves a defect which consistently fails to unite. In response to an implant of 100 mg of bovine bone morphogenetic protein (BMP), the defect becomes filled by callus consisting of fibrocartilage, cartilage and woven bone within four weeks. The cartilage is resorbed and replaced by new bone in four to eight weeks. Woven bone is then resorbed, colonised by bone marrow cells and remodelled into lamellar bone. Union of the defect is produced Key wrote "the diameter of the bone roughly determines the (maximum) length of the section which can be removed from the shaft of this bone and not result in non-union. In adult dogs this length is I times the diameter". Key observed that the insertion of boiled bone, bone powders, calcium salts and other non-viable fillers into the defect produced non-union, while an autogeneic bone graft generally produced solid union. Heiple. Chase and Herndon (1963) used the same model to investigate the process of regeneration in defects of over twice the diameter of the bone and demonstrated that autogeneic bone was superior to both allogeneic bone (whether this was aseptically collected, fresh or freeze-dried, or sterilised by irradiation) and to demineralised bone matrix. Bos et al. (1983) revised Heiple's scoring system, and suggested that tissue typing would improve the results of allogeneic transplants. Goldberg et al. (1984) applied the revised scoring system to investigate the effects of immunosuppression after

We have reviewed 97 consecutive primary hip replacements with a cemented femoral component and a porous-ingrowth acetabular component at a minimum five-year follow-up (average 6.5 years). The average Harris hip score was 93, and 85 hips had no pain or only slight pain. There had been no deterioration in the results since the two-year follow-up. The hybrid hip is successful for up to eight years and appears to be suitable for many patients. Long-term femoral fixation has been shown to improve with second-generation cementing techniques and in this series was excellent with third-generation techniques, in that only one stem was revised for loosening. No cementless acetabular component was revised for loosening.

Cemented Ti-6Al-4V components were used to resurface ten femoral heads in nine young adult patients with osteonecrosis of the femoral head (average age 32 years; range 20 to 51). There were eight hips at Ficat stage III and two at stage IV. Five hips have maintained satisfactory function for an average period of 11.2 years (10 to 12.2) with no radiographic evidence of component loosening or osteolysis; five have been revised after an average period of 7.8 years (3.3 to 10.3) for pain caused by deterioration of the acetabular cartilage. No component required revision for loosening and the specimens retrieved at revision showed no evidence of osteolysis despite burnishing of the titanium bearing surface and the presence of particulate titanium debris in the tissues.

Validation of a wear simulator requires that the device produce a similar type and amount of wear and particles of a comparable morphology as occurs clinically. Using techniques previously established to compare polyethylene particles from hip simulators to those from retrieved tissues, particles isolated from six revised posterior stabilized knee replacements were characterized and compared to particles generated from the same knee design worn in a knee simulator. The particles produced in the knee simulator were of comparable size but had less variability in their form factor compared to the particles produced in vivo. Comparable wear features were seen on the articulating surfaces in both groups. These results indicate that this knee joint simulator is able to reproduce a baseline type of wear that is similar to that in vivo and should encourage further use of this device to better understand knee component wear and function.

Rotational stresses from box-post impingement have been implicated in the loosening of posterior-stabilized total knee prostheses. A bench model was constructed to assess the forces generated by tibiofemoral rotation. Rotational torque under load was measured in two different posteriorstabilized total knee prostheses using an axial-torsion load cell at 0 degrees, 20 degrees, and 40 degrees flexion over 20 degrees internal and external rotation. The Sigma posterior-stabilized prosthesis generated little torque through 5 degrees internal and external rotation. An increase in torque then occurred because of box-post impingement, generating peak torques of 17 to 18 N-m at 12 degrees to 14 degrees rotation. The bench model produced the same deformation of the polyethylene post as seen on retrieved specimens. The Scorpio posterior-stabilized prosthesis had a relatively continuous rise in generated torque from tibiofemoral conformity. Box-post impingement did not occur resulting in 32% lower torque between 12 degrees and 14 degrees rotation. Peak rotational torques of 15 to 16 N-m were reached at 19 degrees to 20 degrees rotation. Tibiofemoral conformity is the primary source of rotational constraint. Box-post impingement can be a source of additional rotational constraint. Depending on specific design features, small changes in relative tibiofemoral component rotation can more than double the generated torque. Axial rotation of the knee in vivo can generate substantial torque. Relative tibiofemoral rotational position is an important factor influencing component function and fixation.

We welcome letters to the Editor concerning articles which have recently been published. Such letters will be subject to the usual stages of selection and editing; where appropriate the authors of the original article will be offered the opportunity to reply.

CORRESPONDENCE THE JOURNAL OF BONE AND JOINT SURGERY is clear on operative exploration through the standard lateral approach which is described, and it is difficult to see how the preoperative classification influences management. The authors cite sustentacular comminution as the main contraindication to surgery, but this part of the fracture is not included in their classification. We consider that the figures for displacement mean little or nothing, and that no case has been made for yet another classification of calcaneal fractures. Further advances in management require a randomised prospective trial of the treatment method described ; this is how management of this fracture will be advanced.