This paper addresses the problem of combining information from independent clinical trials which compare survival distributions of two treatment groups. Current meta-analytic methods which take censoring into account are often not feasible for meta-analyses which synthesize summarized results in published (or unpublished) references, as these methods require information usually not reported. The paper presents methodology which uses the log(-log) survival function difference, (i.e. log(-logS2(t))-log(-logS1(t)), as the contrast index to represent the multiplicative treatment effect on survival in independent trials. This article shows by the second mean value theorem for integrals that this contrast index, denoted as theta, is interpretable as a weighted average on a natural logarithmic scale of hazard ratios within the interval [0,t] in a trial. When the within-trial proportional hazards assumption is true, theta is the logarithm of the proportionality constant for the common hazard ratio for the interval considered within the trial. In this situation, an important advantage of using theta as a contrast index in the proposed methodology is that the estimation of theta is not affected by length of follow-up time. Other commonly used indices such as the odds ratio, risk ratio and risk differences do not have this invariance property under the proportional hazard model, since their estimation may be affected by length of follow-up time as a technical artefact. Thus, the proposed methodology obviates problems which often occur in survival meta-analysis because trials do not report survival at the same length of follow-up time. Even when the within-trial proportional hazards assumption is not realistic, the proposed methodology has the capability of testing a global null hypothesis of no multiplicative treatment effect on the survival distributions of two groups for all studies. A discussion of weighting schemes for meta-analysis is provided, in particular, a weighting scheme based on effective sample sizes is suggested for the meta-analysis of time-to-event data which involves censoring. A medical example illustrating the methodology is given. A simulation investigation suggested that the methodology performs well in the presence of moderate censoring.
Male Novumbra hubbsi are highly aggressive during reproduction when they hold very large territories over long periods of time. A description of aggressive displays, territoriality, and courtship is given from a sample of 29 males in the laboratory and 26 in the field, and the striking convergence in black colors of breeding male sticklebacks and Novumbra where they coexist is considered.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.