Leg length discrepancy following total hip replacement (THR) can contribute to poor hip function. Abnormal gait, pain, neurological disturbance and patient dissatisfaction have all been described as a result of leg length inequality after THR. The purpose of this study was to determine whether the use of computer navigation in THR can improve limb length restoration and early clinical outcomes. We performed a matched-pair study comparing 48 computer-assisted THR with 48 THRs performed using a traditional freehand alignment method. The same implant with a straight non-modular femoral stem was used in all cases. The navigation system used allowed the surgeon to monitor both acetabular cup placement and all the phases of femoral stem implantation including rasping. Patients were matched for age, sex, arthritis level, pre-operative diagnosis and pre-operative leg length discrepancy. At a minimum follow-up of six months, limb length discrepancy was measured using digital radiographs and a standardised protocol. The number of patients with a residual discrepancy of 10 mm or more and/or a postoperative over-lengthening were measured. The clinical outcome was evaluated using both the Harris Hip Score and the normalised Western Ontario and McMaster Universities (WOMAC) Arthritis Index. Restoration of limb length was significantly better in the computerassisted THR group. The number of patients with a residual limb length discrepancy greater than 10 mm and/or a post-operative over-lengthening was significantly lower. No significant difference in the Harris Hip Score or normalised WOMAC Arthritis Index was seen between the two groups. The surgical time was significantly longer in the computer-assisted THR group. No post-operative dislocations were seen.
Patients older than 60 with unicompartmental knee arthritis can be treated with total or unicompartmental knee replacement. The aim of this study was to compare the results of matched paired groups of patients with isolated medial compartment knee arthritis replaced with either UKR (group A) or computer-assisted TKR (group B). The results included 68 knees at a minimum follow-up of 3 years. All patients had a varus deformity no greater than 8º and a BMI lower than 30. Patients were matched in terms of preoperative arthritis severity, age, gender and preoperative range of motion. In the computer-assisted TKR group, all the implants were positioned within 4º of the correct hip-knee-ankle angle and frontal tibial component angle. The surgical time and hospital stay were statistically longer in the CA TKR group. During the study no implant required revision. The results showed higher scores for a UKR in the treatment of isolated primary unicompartmental knee arthritis in patients older than 60 compared to a computer-assisted TKR. In this study a computer-assisted alignment system for TKR with optimal implant positioning did not produce equivalent clinical results compared to a UKR, but did increase the financial costs.Résumé Les patients âgés de plus de 60 ans, présentant une arthrose unicompartimentale du genou ont été traités soit par une prothèse totale, soit par une prothèse unicompartimentale. Le but de cette étude est de comparer les résultats de patients présentant une arthrose fémoro tibiale interne traités par une prothèse unicompartimentale (groupe A), ou par prothèse totale du genou mise en place par chirurgie assistée par ordinateur (groupe B). Les résultats incluent 68 genoux avec un suivi minimum de 3 ans. Tous les patients avaient une déformation en varus inferiure à 8 degrés et un BMI inférieur à 30. Les patients ont été comparés en fonction du degré d'arthrose, de l'âge, du sexe et de la mobilité pré opératoire. Dans la série prothèse totale, tous les implants ont été positionnés avec une marge de 4°par rapport à l'angle hanche cheville. Le temps opératoire et la durée d'hospitalisation ont été statistiquement plus importants dans le groupe prothèse totale. Aucun implant n'a nécessité de révision. Les résultats montrent que le score est bien meilleur dans les prothèses unicompartimentales pour le traitement des arthroses unicompartimentales, chez ces patients âgés de plus de 60 ans, comparé au traitement par prothèse totale avec chirurgie assistée par ordinateur. Cette étude montre que la mise en place par chirurgie assistée par ordinateur d'une prothèse totale du genou avec un positionnement optimal des implants peut donner un résultat équivalent à celui des prothèses unicompartimentales mais augmente le coût financier du traitement.
IntroductionRecent trends in knee reconstructive surgery have included less invasive surgical approaches along with preserving
The results of this 48 months follow-up study suggest that Bi-UKR is a viable option for bicompartmental tibio-femoral arthritis at least as well as TKR but maintaining a higher level of function.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.