A study was conducted to determine the effect of some wood characteristics such as species, moisture content and tree part on the performance and product quality offered by a mobile industrial chipper, of the type commonly used for roadside chipping. Two main species, two tree parts and two moisture content levels were combined in a factorial design yielding 8 treatments, each replicated 5 or 6 times. A flow meter was installed on the chipper engine, and all chips produced were weighed and sampled for moisture content and particle size distribution. The results indicated that some wood characteristics such as species and moisture content have a secondary effect on chipper productivity and fuel consumption, which are primarily controlled by piece size. In particular, fuel consumption per unit dry mass seem to be rather constant and in the range of 3.2 l per oven dry ton. Moisture content and tree part may have a significant effect on the particle size distribution of chips. Of course, these results were only verified for the species used in the test and for industrial chippers, and may change if substantially different species or machines are used.
The authors tested two mini-yarders, one for uphill and the other for downhill extraction. The two machines were modern commercial models, offering state-of-the-art yarding technology on a miniature scale and at a much lower cost than required for purchasing a full-size tower yarder. The two units must not be regarded as alternative, but rather as complementary, since they offer different capabilities and advantages. Both machines were tested while harvesting firewood from the thinning of young beech stands in Central Italy. The tests indicated that both units can reach a productivity between 1.5 and 2.4 m 3 SMH -1 , including all delays, as well as set-up and dismantle time. Calculated extraction cost ranged between 24 and over 30€ m -3 . The authors calculated a set of regression equations for estimating machine productivity as a function of the main work conditions. The performance of the studied mini-yarders does not seem much inferior to that achieved by professional light tower yarder under the same work conditions, but the lighter construction of the small-scale units may result in a lower resistance to wear and abuse. In any case, mini-yarders seem ideal for deployment under the typical conditions of small-scale forestry, offering a good solution to wood extraction on steep terrain, competitive with animal and winch logging in terms of productivity, cost and operator comfort. R. Spinelli (&) CNR, Timber and Tree Institute,
The effect of mechanization level and harvesting system on the thinning cost of Mediterranean softwood plantations Spinelli R., Lombardini C., Magagnotti N. (2014). The effect of mechanization level and harvesting system on the thinning cost of Mediterranean softwood plantations. Silva Fennica vol. 48 no. 1 article id 1003. 15 p.
Highlights• Whole-tree harvesting is 40-50% cheaper than cut-to-length harvesting.• Mechanization reduced thinning cost by a factor 4.• Between 1.5 and 6% of the residual trees were damaged.• Mechanized cut-to-length harvesting allows controlled biomass release.• Mechanized whole-tree harvesting is the cheapest option for energy chip production.
AbstractThe study compared motor-manual cut-to-length (CTL) harvesting, motor-manual whole-tree (WT) harvesting, mechanized CTL harvesting and mechanized WT harvesting as applied to the production of energy chips from the second thinning of Mediterranean pine plantations in flat terrain. Mechanization increased productivity between 6 and 20 times, depending on process step. It also allowed reducing thinning cost by a factor 4. Shifting from CTL to WT harvesting resulted in a reduction of harvesting cost between 40 and 50%. Fuel consumption was between 40 and 100% higher for CTL harvesting than for WT harvesting. Mechanization entailed a reduction of fuel consumption between 10 and 40%. Stand damage was generally low, between 1.5 and 6%. Mechanized CTL harvesting resulted in the lowest incidence of wounding, and the difference between mechanized CTL and manual WT harvesting was statistically significant. Soil compaction was absent or very small, depending on treatment. Mechanized thinning may produce larger increases of soil bulk density, compared to motor-manual thinning, but the difference is small, although significant. CTL harvesting leaves a larger amount of biomass on the soil, which relieves possible concerns about soil nutrient depletion. On the other hand, heavy residue loads may increase fire risk especially in sensitive Mediterranean environments.
The authors developed a general productivity model for the harvesters and processors currently used in Italy. The model consists of a set of mathematical relationships that can estimate the productivity of these machines under the whole range of specific work conditions faced in Italy. Such relationships can provide general directions to prospective users and can contribute to the development of scenario predictions. The original data pool contained more than 15,000 individual timestudy records, each representing a single harvesting cycle (most often one tree). The records were extracted from 38 studies conducted with the same methods and by the same principal investigators between 1998 and 2008. Statistically significant models were developed for all cyclic work phases, such as moving, brushing, felling, and processing. Accessory time and delay time were added as percent factors, also estimated from the same studies. Model development aimed at achieving the best compromise solution between accuracy and easy use, avoiding the introduction of an excessively large number of input variables. Selected independent variables were tree volume, tree species, task type (harvesting or processing), machine power and type, density of residual stand and of harvest trees, stand type, and slope gradient. These models could predict a large proportion of the variability in the data and were successfully validated using reserved cycle records, extracted from the same data pool and not used for model development. Comparison with similar Nordic and German standards confirmed the sound structure of the Italian models while highlighting the need for specific productivity norms due to the different work conditions faced by Italian operators.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.