T he laryngeal mask airway (LMA) has advantages over tracheal intubation, but failure rates are a concern. The predictors of LMA failure in adults have been determined in various studies, but similar data for children are scarce. This retrospective observational study was undertaken to determine the incidence of and risk factors for LMA Unique (disposable mask) (Cardinal Health, Dublin, OH) and LMA Classic (reusable mask) (LMA North America, San Diego, CA) failure in pediatric surgical patients.The review included data on all children (<18 years old) who received a laryngeal mask anesthetic during the period 2006 to 2010, when these 2 LMAs were the only ones used at the authors' institution. All hospital-based and outpatient sites and repeat procedures were included. Variables included preoperative and intraoperative factors associated with adverse respiratory events. The primary outcome was LMA failure, defined as abandonment of the LMA and subsequent tracheal intubation. Secondary outcomes included the timing of the primary outcome relative to surgical incision and presenting features of the mask failure. SPSS version 20.0 (SPAA Inc, Chicago, Ill)was used for all analyses, with significance at P < 0.05.Of 11,921 pediatric anesthesia cases performed during the study period, 188 had an intraoperative direct laryngoscopy or placement of an endotracheal tube. Of these, 102 were actually the result of LMA failure and not changes in surgical plans, use as a rescue airway, or replaced because of communication failures. The LMA failure rate was 0.86% (~1/117 cases). Overall failure rates were substantially increased for mask sizes 1.5 and 5; other sizes were not associated with increased failure rates. Fifty-eight failures (57%) occurred before surgical incision and 44 (43%) after incision. The presenting features for LMA failure were leak or inadequate seal in 25 cases (25%). Obstruction was reported in 49 cases, in which 38 were upper airway and 11 lower airway events (37% and 10% of total, respectively). Patient intolerance reflected as hiccoughing, bucking, or coughing was the primary cause in 11 cases (11%) and a combination of these features, classified as "other" occurred in 17 cases (17%). The 5 independent predictors of LMA failure were ear/nose/throat procedure, inpatient/admit day of surgery admission status, prolonged surgical duration, congenital/acquired airway abnormality, and patient transport.These 2 LMAs have relatively low failure rates and can be used reliably in children. However, the predictors of LMA failure in children are not the same as those in adults and should be independently considered. These results should decrease the dependence on anecdotal evidence for use of LMAs in young patients.
COMMENTThis article by Mathis et al is a retrospective observational study of LMA failure in children that examines clinical predictors of such failure. The authors included data on all children (<18 years old) who underwent general anesthesia with an LMA during the period 2006 to 2010. Of the 11,921 such ...