Over the last century, several different theoretical models have been proposed for the calculation of the transverse modulus of fibres or cylinders from compression experiments. Whilst they all give similar results, the differences are significant enough to cause errors in computer simulation predictions of composite properties, and hence the issue warrants further investigation. Two independent approaches were applied to clarify this. Firstly, using an experimental approach, compression tests have been carried out on model elastic cylinders of poly(methyl methacrylate) as well as cuboids machined from the cylinders. The transverse modulus of this hard elastic material was determined directly from compression experiments on the cuboids and by analysis using different models for the cylinder compression data. Since machining was shown to change the modulus by virtue of relieving stresses in the samples, comparison was made between cuboids and machined cylinders. The transverse modulus obtained by direct compression of the cuboids was statistically equivalent to that obtained from the cylinders using the Morris model and was within 8% of the value obtained using the model derived by Jawad and Ward, as well as the mathematically equivalent models derived by Phoenix and Skelton and Lundberg. Finally, the separate and independent approach of finite element numerical modelling was also utilised. The finite element approach gave results that lie between the Jawad and Ward and Morris models. The close agreement in the outcomes of the finite element modelling and the experimental approach leads to the conclusion that the most accurate of the different analytical models are the equations by Morris as well as those due to Jawad and Ward, Phoenix and Skelton and Lundberg.
The performance of carbon fibers depends on the properties of the precursor polyacrylonitrile (PAN) fibers. Stretching of PAN fibers results in improved tensile properties, while potentially reducing its compressive properties. To determine optimization trade-offs, the effect of coagulation conditions and the stretching process on the compressive modulus in the transverse direction (ET) was investigated. A method for accurately determining ET from polymer fibers with non-circular cross-sectional shapes is presented. X-ray diffraction was used to measure the crystallite size, crystallinity, and crystallite orientation of the fibers. ET was found to increase with decreasing crystallite orientation along the drawing direction, which decreases the tensile modulus in the longitudinal direction (EL) proportionally to crystallite orientation. Stretching resulted in greater crystallite orientation along the drawing direction for fibers formed under the same coagulation conditions. Increasing the solvent concentration in the coagulation bath resulted in a higher average orientation, but reduced the impact of stretching on the orientation. The relationship between ET and EL observed in the precursor PAN fiber is retained after carbonization, with a 20% increase in ET achieved for a 2% decrease in EL. This indicates that controlled stretching of PAN fiber allows for highly efficient trading off of EL for ET in carbon fiber.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.