Plasma exchange is more effective than plasma infusion in the treatment of thrombotic thrombocytopenic purpura.

Eighteen patients with definite, untreated chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyradiculoneuropathy (CIDP) of chronic progressive (nine patients) or relapsing course (nine patients) were randomized prospectively to receive 10 plasma-exchange (PE) or sham plasma-exchange (SPE) treatments over 4 weeks in a double-blind trial. After a wash-out period of 5 weeks or when they returned to baseline scores, patients were crossed over to the alternate treatments. Neurological function was assessed serially using a quantitative neurological disability score (NDS), a functional clinical grade (CG) and grip strength (GS) measurements. Electrophysiological studies were done at the beginning and end of each treatment. A primary 'intention to treat' analysis showed significant improvement with PE in all clinical outcome measures: NDS by 38 points, P < 0.001; CG by 1.6 points, P < 0.001; GS by +13 kg, P < 0.003 and in selected electrophysiological measurements, sigma proximal CMAP, P < 0.01; sigma motor conduction velocities, P < 0.006; sigma distal motor latencies, P < 0.01. Fifteen patients completed the trial and of those, 12 patients (80%) improved substantially with PE; i.e. five out of seven patients with chronic progressive course and seven out of eight patients with relapsing CIDP improved. There were three drop-outs; one patient lost venous access; one patient suffered a stroke and one patient left the trial to receive open treatment elsewhere. The improvement in motor functions correlated with the electrophysiological data, i.e. with improved motor conduction velocities and reversal of conduction block. Eight of 12 PE responders (66%) relapsed within 7-14 days after stopping PE. All improved with subsequent open label PE; all but two patients required long-term immunosuppressive drug therapy for stabilization. The PE non-responders improved with prednisone. We conclude that PE is a very effective adjuvant therapy for CIDP of both chronic progressive and relapsing course; concurrent immunosuppressive drug treatment is required. Exchange treatments should be given two to three times per week until improvement is established; the treatment frequency should then be tapered over several months.

More than one third of patients who survive an acute episode of thrombotic thrombocytopenic purpura will have at least one relapse during the following 10 years.

The current established treatment of thrombotic thrombocytopenic purpura (TTP) is plasma exchange with fresh frozen plasma (FEP). With this treatment, there is a 49% response after seven exchanges and a 78% survival at 1 month. Although the exact cause of TTP is unknown, the presence of von Willebrand factor (VWF) multimers has been implicated in the disease. Accordingly, it has been suggested that cryosupernatant (plasma from which cryoprecipitate has been removed), which is relatively deficient in VWF multimers, might be an effective replacement fluid during plasma exchange. Patients from six centers were treated by plasma exchange with cryosupernatant. 18 patients who had failed a first course (average 7.7 exchanges) of plasma exchange with FFP. received a further seven exchanges with cryosupernatant. Subsequently, 40 previously untreated patients were exchanged with cryosupernatant. Of the 18 previously treated patients, 11 responded (defined as an increase in platelet count to > 150 x 10(9) /1 and no neurological events) after seven exchanges and 15 (83%) of the patients were alive at 1 month. The response rate in the 40 previously untreated patients was 75% at the end of seven exchanges and 95% of the patients were alive at 1 month. These values are significantly different (P < 0.05) from those reported in our earlier study and in other patients concurrently treated at the same centres with FFP when cryosupernatant was not available. Some patients who have failed to respond to plasma exchange with FFP replacement will respond to further exchange with cryosupernatant. Cryosupernatant replacement may be more effective as first-line treatment of TTP than FFP.

Thrombotic thrombocytopenic purpura is an uncommon disorder that requires prompt recognition and intervention to prevent death. To date, information regarding the classic laboratory abnormalities in the disease has been derived from small numbers of patients whose laboratory tests have been done at many different sites. We report the laboratory findings in 135 patients who presented with thrombotic thrombocytopenic purpura to 17 Canadian centres. 50 men and 85 women had a mean platelet count of 25.3+/-19.4x10(9)/l. The initial platelet count correlated with mortality; 32% of patients with a platelet count of 20x10(9)/l or less died compared with 18% of patients with a platelet count >20x10(9)/l (P=0.058). The platelet-associated IgG was elevated in 88% at presentation whereas the indirect platelet suspension immunofluorescence test was positive in only 18%, 93% of the sera showed reactivity against platelets following protein blotting. All sera tested also showed reactivity against endothelial cells. Immune complexes were seen in all patients, whereas the platelet aggregating factor was detected in 59%. Although the von Willebrand factor was elevated in the majority of patients at entry, the multimer pattern was variable and showed no predictive pattern. Renal dysfunction was common (18%).

In 1997, the Canadian Apheresis Group reviewed data on 103,416 plasma exchange procedures that had been collected since 1980. Although the number of plasma exchanges gradually increased (from 3189 to 8208 per year), the pattern changed. In 1981, the five most frequent indications for plasma exchange resulted in 55% of all such procedures; by 1997, the five most frequent indications for plasma exchange resulted in 81.1% of all such procedures. During this period, three conditions that were originally among the most frequent indications for plasma exchange became among the least frequent. This paper reviews the published evidence that supports or refutes the use of plasma exchange in the category of the five most frequent indications from 1981 to 1997: thrombotic thrombocytopenic purpura, myasthenia gravis, chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy, Waldenstrom macroglobulinemia, the Guillain-Barre syndrome, rheumatoid arthritis, systemic lupus erythematosus, and multiple sclerosis. For most disorders, use of plasma exchange procedures is correlated with published evidence, and the changing patterns of plasma exchange use by members of the Canadian Apheresis Group reflect published evidence. Annual center-by-center reviews of use of plasma exchange may also have influenced practice patterns.

No abstract

No abstract