SummaryPethidine is reported to be more effective than equi-analgesic doses of other opioids as an inhibitor of postanaesthetic shivering. The aim of this study was to verifv whether this action resulted from a local anaesthetic effect of pethidine or from inadequate fentanyl dosage in previous studies. We studied 52 ASA I or Zpatients. They were randomly allocated, in a double -blind fashion, to one of four groups to receive either pethidine (0.85mg.kg-') or fentanyl (I. 7pg.kg-')
kg-I).
Key wordsComplications; shivering. Analgesics; fentanyl, pethidine. Anaesthetics, local; lignocaine.Shivering is a normal thermoregulatory response to perioperative hypothermia, which can be modified by opioids [I+. The degree of inhibition seems to depend on the specific drug administered and whereas pethidine is a well recognised treatment [5, 61, other p agonists, including fentanyl [5] and morphine [5, 61, have proved less successful. Explanations for the reported discrepancy between pethidine and fentanyl may be that these drugs were not compared at an equivalent dosage or that pethidine acts peripherally [5, 71. Apart from its opioid effects [8], pethidine possesses other pharmacological properties [9-121, including a membrane stabilising effect [9]. It is well established that lignocaine I mg.kg-', when administered intravenously, has an analgesic effect [I 31 probably mediated through A6 and C fibres [14], both of which transmit thermal inputs from cutaneous receptors [I 51. The peripheral effect of pethidine could be associated with this property.The aims of this double-blind, controlled study were ( I ) to verify if, at higher dosage, pethidine and fentanyl had comparative effects on postanaesthetic shivering and (2) to investigate the possibility, using lignocaine, that the superiority of pethidine could be attributed to its stabilising membrane effect.
MethodWith the approval of the local ethics committee, 465 postoperative ASA 1 or 2 adults were studied. They had all received a general anaesthetic lasting at least I h for noninfective orthopaedic or abdominal surgery. Anaesthesia was induced with thiopentone (5 mg.kg-' ) and fentanyl (2 pg.kg-'). Tracheal intubation was facilitated with vecuronium (0. I mg.kg-l). Anaesthesia was maintained with isoflurane and fentanyl as required.On arrival in the recovery room, the criteria for inclusion in the study were as follows: spontaneous ventilation, a core temperature below 36°C and vigorous shivering. Fifty-two patients met these criteria and were studied using a doubleblind design. Patients were randomly allocated to receive either pethidine (0.85 mg. kg-I) (n = 13), fentanyl (1.7pg.kg-I) (n = 13), lignocaine I mg.kg-' (n = 13) or