No abstract

Idiosyncratic drug reactions are difficult to study in humans due to their unpredictability. Unfortunately, this characteristic also hinders the development of animal models needed for mechanistic studies. Nevirapine, used to treat human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infections, results in a severe idiosyncratic skin rash in some patients. We found that nevirapine can also cause a significant rash in some strains of rats. At a dose of 150 mg/kg/day, the incidence in female Sprague-Dawley rats was 6/28 (21%), in female Brown Norway rats 32/32 (100%), and in female Lewis rats 0/6 (0%) while no male Sprague-Dawley or Brown Norway rats developed a rash. Female SJL mice 0/7 also did not develop nevirapine-induced skin lesions. The first sign of a reaction in Brown Norway rats was red ears at days 7-10 followed by a rash with scabbing mainly on the back; this was a shorter time to onset than in Sprague-Dawley rats. Light microscopy of the skin revealed a primarily mononuclear inflammatory infiltrate and lesions typical of self-trauma. Immunohistochemistry results suggest that the infiltrate was composed of CD4 and CD8 T cells as well as macrophages. A lower dose of either 40 or 75 mg/kg/day did not lead to a rash and, in fact, 2 weeks of the lower doses induced tolerance to the 150 mg/kg/day dose in female Brown Norway rats. A dose of 100 mg/kg/day resulted in rash in 2/4 (50%) of female Brown Norway rats. Rechallenge of Brown Norway rats that had been allowed to recuperate after a nevirapine-induced rash led to red ears in less than 24 h followed by hair loss and occasional skin lesions. Although the skin rash was less evident on rechallenge, microscopically, the cellular infiltrate was more prominent, especially surrounding the hair follicles. Moreover, there were lesions of interface dermatitis with apoptosis and satellitosis, indicative of a cell-mediated immune attack on the epidermis. While systemic signs of illness did not accompany the rash on primary exposure, on rechallenge, the animals appeared generally unwell and this forced sacrifice after 2 weeks or less of treatment. Importantly, splenocytes isolated from rechallenged animals were able to transfer susceptibility to nevirapine-induced skin rash to naïve female Brown Norway recipients, which was illustrated by a faster time to onset of rash in the recipients. The characteristics of this adverse reaction are similar to that seen in humans; that is, it is idiosyncratic in that it only occurs in some strains of animals, is delayed in onset, is more common in females, is dose-dependent, and appears to be immune-mediated. Therefore, it may represent a good animal model for the study of idiosyncratic drug reactions.

No abstract

Previously, we reported a new animal model of an idiosyncratic drug reaction in which nevirapine causes a skin rash in some rats that has characteristics similar to the reaction that occurs in humans. Strong evidence that the reaction is immune-mediated was found; specifically, low-dose pretreatment induced tolerance, while with rechallenge, the time to onset decreased and the severity increased. Furthermore, splenocytes from rechallenged rats transferred rash susceptibility to naïve recipients. We now report the results of studies to explore the immune aspects of this reaction. T cells were found to play an important role, as demonstrated by their ability to adoptively transfer susceptibility to the skin reaction. Of these T cells, CD4+ cells are the likely effectors because they were capable of transferring susceptibility and the reaction was delayed in rats partially depleted of CD4+ T cells. In contrast, it appears that CD8+ T cells are not essential, as CD8+ T cells were unable to transfer sensitivity to a naïve animal and rats depleted of CD8+ T cells still developed skin rash. Unlike the penicillamine model, where we have demonstrated that the tolerance induced by low-dose treatment is immune-mediated, tolerance induced by low-dose nevirapine appears to be largely due to induction of metabolism as it can be overcome by inhibition of cytochrome P450. Pretreatment with the immunosuppressants, cyclosporine and tacrolimus, prevented the rash and even led to resolution of the rash during nevirapine treatment. These studies reinforce the hypothesis that the reaction in this model is similar to that which occurs in humans. In particular, the finding that CD4+ T cells may play a central role in this model fits with the observation that the incidence of idiosyncratic reactions to nevirapine in humans appears to be lower in patients with low CD4+ counts.

Perfluorooctanesulfonate (PFOS) is a stable and environmentally persistent metabolic or degradation product of perfluorooctanyl compounds that were manufactured for a variety of industrial and consumer applications. PFOS itself was sold for use as a surfactant. The structurally related contaminants perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA), perfluorodecanoic acid (PFDA), and N-ethyl perfluorooctane sulfonamide (N-EtPFOSA) were shown to suppress immune responses in laboratory rodents. Relatively low doses of PFOS were found to be immunosuppressive in mice. To assess effects of PFOS on the rat immune system at doses known to alter hepatic function, changes in the morphology and function of immune tissues and cells were measured in adult rats exposed to PFOS in their diet for 28 d at levels ranging from 2 to 100 mg PFOS/kg diet (corresponding to approximately 0.14 to 7.58 mg/kg body weight [bw]/d) and compared to those receiving control diet. Body weight reductions were significant in male and female rats exposed to 50 and 100 mg PFOS/kg diet. Liver/body weight was significantly increased in females exposed to 2 mg PFOS/kg diet and in males exposed to 20 mg PFOS/kg diet. Female rats exposed to 100 mg PFOS/kg diet exhibited a significant increase in spleen weight relative to body weight; these changes lacked a histologic correlate and were not observed in males. While thymus weights relative to body weights were not affected, numbers of apoptotic lymphocytes rose in thymus with increasing dietary PFOS. There was a significant dose-related increase in total peripheral blood lymphocyte numbers in female but not male rats. In both genders the percentages of cells within lymphocyte subclasses were altered. There was a significant trend toward increasing T and T-helper (Th) cells and decreasing B cells with higher PFOS dose. Serum total immunoglobulin (Ig) G1 levels were significantly reduced in males exposed to 2 and 20 mg PFOS/kg diet. The ability of male and female rats to mount delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) responses to the T-cell-dependent antigen keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) was not altered by PFOS. There was a significant trend toward elevated KLH-specific IgG in serum from male rats exposed to increasing levels of PFOS in diet. Splenic T- and B-cell proliferation in response to ex vivo mitogen exposure was unaffected by exposure to dietary PFOS. In conclusion, changes in immune parameters in rat did not manifest as functional alterations in response to immune challenge with KLH and may be secondary to hepatic-mediated effects of PFOS in this model.

Currently, there is a multitude of CD3 bispecifics with different molecular designs and binding properties in preclinical and clinical development for the treatment of liquid or solid tumors. The key safety concerns with CD3 bispecifics are excessive release of cytokines, which may translate to potentially life-threating cytokine release syndrome (CRS), target organ toxicity due to redirection of T-cells to normal tissues expressing the tumor-associated antigen (TAA) (off-tumor/on-target cytotoxicity), and, in some instances, neurotoxicity. Another key challenge is to arrive at a safe clinical starting dose and an efficient escalating strategy that allows patients in early dose cohorts the potential for clinical benefit in Phase 1 trials. To expand the therapeutic index and bring more treatment options to patients, there are intense efforts to overcome these challenges through improvements in molecular design, preclinical safety assessment strategies, and clinical management practices. A recent workshop at the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) with industry, academic, and regulatory agency representation was held to discuss the challenges and explore where such improvements to the development of CD3 bispecifics can be implemented. Here, the content of the presentations and the discussion that occurred during this workshop are summarized. ARTICLE HISTORY

Nevirapine, used for the treatment of HIV infection, is associated with development of skin rash and liver toxicity. The mechanism of these idiosyncratic reactions is unknown. We have previously reported the discovery of a new animal model of nevirapine-induced skin rash in rats. When treated with nevirapine, Brown Norway rats developed red ears on about day 7 and skin rash on about day 21. On rechallenge, ears turn red within 24 h, and skin lesions develop by day 9. In the current study, we analyzed the time course of the sequence of events involved in the development of skin rash. Rats were treated with nevirapine for 7, 14, or 21 days or rechallenged with it for 0, 1, or 9 days. This treatment led to an increase in the total number of auricular lymph node T, B, and macrophage cells. There was also an increase in the activation/infiltration marker ICAM-1 and activation/antigen presentation marker MHC II in these cells compared with those from control rats. Immunohistochemistry analysis showed macrophage infiltration and ICAM-1 expression in the ears of treated rats as early as day 7 of treatment. Macrophage infiltration preceded T cell infiltration, which was not apparent until the onset of rash. Both MHC I and MHC II expression increased in the skin of nevirapine-treated rats that developed rash. A major inducer of MHC is IFNgamma. Although rechallenge with nevirapine led to a large increase in serum levels of IFNgamma, this was not observed during the treatment of naïve rats with nevirapine. These observations provide further clues to the mechanism of nevirapine-induced skin rash.

Treatment of HIV-1 infections with nevirapine is associated with skin and liver toxicity. These two organ toxicities range from mild to severe, in rare cases resulting in life-threatening liver failure or toxic epidermal necrolysis. The study of the mechanistic steps leading to nevirapine-induced skin rash has been facilitated by the discovery of an animal model in which nevirapine causes a skin rash in rats that closely mimics the rash reported in patients. The similarity in characteristics of the rash between humans and rats strongly suggests that the basic mechanism is the same in both. The rash is clearly immune-mediated in rats, and partial depletion of CD4(+) T cells, but not CD8(+) T cells, is protective. We have demonstrated that the rash is related to the 12-hydroxylation of nevirapine rather than to the parent drug. This is presumably because the 12-hydroxy metabolite can be converted to a reactive quinone methide in skin, but that remains to be demonstrated. Although the rash is clearly related to the 12-hydroxy metabolite rather than the parent drug, cells from rechallenged animals respond ex vivo to the parent drug by producing cytokines such as interferon-gamma with little response to the 12-hydroxy metabolite, even when the rash was induced by treatment with the metabolite rather than the parent drug. This indicates that the response of T cells in vitro cannot be used to determine what caused an immune response. We are now studying the detailed steps by which the 12-hydroxy metabolite induces an immune response and skin rash. This animal model provides a unique tool to study the mechanistic details of an idiosyncratic drug reaction; however, it is likely that there are significant differences in the mechanisms of different idiosyncratic drug reactions, and therefore the results of these studies cannot safely be generalized to all idiosyncratic drug reactions.