Su m m ary. The role of the city in environ m ental m anagem ent is in creasin gly com ing to the fore. A cen tral elem en t in creatin g urban environ m ental sustain ability is the adop tion of approp riate en ergy p olicies, since m ost environ m ental extern alities in cities are directly or indirectly related to energy u se. The cu rren t p ractice d em onstrates an overw helm ing variety of initiative s and policies, so th at the actu al su ccess of such strategi es in a cross-sect ional com parative persp ective is hard to evalu ate. In this con text, this paper offers an application of m eta-an alysis, as this approach is an interestin g an alytical con trib ution tow ard s a better understan ding of th e critical success factors of urb an en ergy policies. The paper starts with a gen eral overview of th e issu e of urban sustain ab ility and sets out the im p ortan ce of energy p olicies at th e urban level. It con tin ues by offerin g a m ethodological fram ew ork for the assessm ent of critical factors related to the perform an ce of sustain able energy strategi es. Using a datab ase con tain ing inform ation on exp erien ces an d exp ert exp ectation s regard ing ren ew able en ergy initiative s in 12 Europ ean cities spread over 3 cou ntries (Italy, The N eth erlan ds and G reece), w e offer a cross-E urop ean com p arative analysis of the perform an ce of urban renew able energy tech n ologies. This com parative analysis con sists of a statistic al exp lanation based on a prob it analysis of urb an su stain ability data and the application of a speci® c m eta-an alytical m ethod, called rou gh set analysis. The paper ends with a con clu ding section on p olicy lesson s.
P eter Nijkam p and Gerard P epping are in the
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.