A quantitative model for describing the within‐population variation in planktonic foraminifer shell chemistry that results from secondary calcification and selective dissolution is presented. The objective is to construct a basis for inferring the chemistries of different shell components and estimating the extent of shell dissolution. Variation is modeled as mixtures of two kinds of shell calcite, a primary calcite that forms the chambers and a secondary calcite that forms crust. Bulk shell chemistries are intermediate between the chemistries of these calcites and lie on mixing lines between them. For two component systems, mass balance relationships can be reformulated as a linear regression and solved for the chemistries of the primary and secondary calcites and for the uncertainties associated with these estimates. To apply this model, one needs measurements of bulk shell chemistries and estimates of the relative proportions of secondary and primary calcites. For most planktonic foraminifer species the proportion of secondary calcite can be estimated from differences in the relationship between shell size and mass before and after crusting. Preliminary results are consistent with previous work showing that secondary calcites are added at depth. However, even deep‐dwelling species appear to grow most of their primary shell in surface waters and some surface‐dwelling species add secondary calcite in the deep ocean. In contrast to the model's simple description of secondary calcification, the variation in chemistry from selective dissolution is more complicated because undissolved shells are themselves mixtures of primary and secondary calcites and therefore present a wide range of initial shell compositions. Nevertheless, the model allows both the compositions of different components to be inferred and the amount of dissolution to be estimated. Preliminary results indicate that dissolution of planktonic foraminifera is apparent nearly 2 km above the foraminifer lysocline and even apparently well‐preserved shells may be over 50% dissolved.
Abstract. Using bathymetric transects of surface sediments underlying similar sea surface temperatures but exposed to increasing dissolution, we examined the processes which affect the relationship between foraminiferal Mg/Ca and 5180. We found that Globigerinoides saccculifer calcifies over a relatively large range of water depth and that this is apparent in their Mg content. On the seafloor, foraminiferal Mg/Ca is substantially altered by dissolution with the degree of alteration increasing with water depth. Selective dissolution of the chamber calcite, formed in surface waters, shifts the shell's bulk Mg/Ca and 5180 toward the chemistries of the secondary crust acquired in colder thermocline waters. The magnitude of this shift depends on both the range of temperatures over which the shell calcified and the degree to which it is subsequently dissolved. In spite of this shift the initial relationship between Mg/Ca and 5180, determined by their temperature dependence, is maintained. We conclude that paired measurements of 5180 and Mg/Ca can be used for reconstructing 518Owater, though care must be taken to determine where in the water column the reconstruction applies.
[1] Paired d
18O and Mg/Ca measurements on the same foraminiferal shells offer the ability to independently estimate sea surface temperature (SST) changes and assess their temporal relationship to the growth and decay of continental ice sheets. The accuracy of this method is confounded, however, by the absence of a quantitative method to correct Mg/Ca records for alteration by dissolution. Here we describe dissolution-corrected calibrations for Mg/Ca-paleothermometry in which the preexponent constant is a function of size-normalized shell weight: (1) . The new calibrations improve the accuracy of SST estimates and are globally applicable. With this correction, eastern equatorial Atlantic SST during the Last Glacial Maximum is estimated to be 2.9°± 0.4°C colder than today.
The warm-water planktonic foraminiferal Globorotalia tumida lineage has been studied in a 10-Myr-long stratigraphic sequence (Late Miocene through Recent) from the Indian Ocean to determine long-term evolutionary patterns through the lineage's history, and particularly to study in great detail the evolutionary transition from G. plesiotumida to G. tumida across the Miocene/Pliocene boundary. Sampling resolution was very good, between 5 × 103 and 15 × 103 yr across the Miocene/Pliocene boundary and about 2 × 105 yr otherwise. The test shape was analyzed in edge view, permitting determinations of variation in inflation and elongation of the test. Shape was analyzed quantitatively using eigenshape analysis. This method represents the greatest proportion of variation observed among a collection of shapes by the least number of different shapes. The Late Miocene (10.4-5.6 Myr B.P.) populations exhibited only minor fluctuations in shape that did not result in any net phyletic change. This period of stasis was followed by an 0.6-Myr-long period (between 5.6 and 5.0 Myr B.P.) of gradual transformation of the Late Miocene morphotype (G. plesiotumida) into the Early Pliocene morphotype (G. tumida). The populations were again more or less in stasis in the Pliocene and Pleistocene (5.0 Myr to the present day), so that no major modifications of the newly evolved Early Pliocene morphotype occurred during these 5 Myr. Thus it would appear that the G. tumida lineage, while remaining in relative stasis over a considerable part of its total duration underwent periodic, relatively rapid, morphologic change that did not lead to lineage branching. This pattern does not conform to the gradualistic model of evolution, because that would assume gradual changes throughout the history of the lineage. It also does not conform to the punctuational model, because (1) there was no speciation (lineage branching) in this lineage and (2) the transition was not rapid enough (<1% of the descendant species' duration according to definition). For this evolutionary modality we propose the term “punctuated gradualism” and suggest that this may be a common norm for evolution—at least within the planktonic foraminifera.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.