This study presents the results of a meta-analysis based on the literature dealing with the clinical applications of vacuum-assisted closure (VAC) in the areas of chronic wounds, acute posttraumatic wounds, compartment syndromes, or injuries of the upper extremities. The studies were analysed for validity, significance of conclusion with respect to success rate, publications, and economic efficacy. The data show that with VAC a very valuable technique has been added to an integrated therapeutic concept of soft tissue reconstruction. However, clinical data from prospective randomised trials to support some of the positive aspects seen in the daily clinical application of the technique are still missing. These would create a sound basis demonstrating the economic efficacy of the technique.
The gap between the broad clinical use of vacuum-assisted closure therapy (VT) and knowledge of the physiological mechanisms leading to its effectiveness is great. The value of the technique and its future development are dependent on research into these mechanisms. A meta-analysis evaluating the results of basic research on the effectiveness of VT was carried out based on peer reviewed publications. This is considered in relation to other therapeutic approaches of basic research to wound healing (growth factors etc.). Our study includes a concise description of the scientific background to the mechanisms of cell stimulation using basic work on tissue expansion, bone, vessel and nerve distraction as well as in vitro cell stimulation. Evaluation of the scientific data on all known effects of VT was made based on the results from experimental animal studies, the results of randomized clinical studies, observations on clinical applications and case reports. Assessment of the studies was based on design and significance as well as the appraisal of our own clinical experience. Data involving cellular effects (proliferation, synthesis, wound healing), systemic effects (mediators, systemic inflammatory disease), extracellular effects (perfusion, edema, local wound environment, stabilization, barriers) and complex effects of VT (inflammation, matrix function, blood supply) were examined. Systematic analysis of the data allows scientifically interested surgeons rapid access to the theme, the first, to this extent, extensive overview of the current scientific situation as well as a comprehensive bibliography for all areas involving the theme of mechanical cell stimulation. The authors list major areas for future research and encourage the development of multicenter studies.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.