Enhanced phosphorus (P) release from soils to overlying water under flooded, anaerobic conditions has been well documented for noncalcareous and surface soils, but little information is available for calcareous and subsurface soils. We compared the magnitude of P released from 12 calcareous surface soils and corresponding subsurface soils to overlying water under flooded, anaerobic conditions and examined the reasons for the differences. Surface (0-15 cm) and subsurface (15-30 cm) soils were packed into vessels and flooded for 8 wk. Soil redox potential and concentrations of dissolved reactive phosphorus (DRP) and total dissolved Ca, Mg, Fe, and Mn in floodwater and pore water were measured weekly. Soil test P was significantly smaller in subsurface soils than in corresponding surface soils; thus, the P release to floodwater from subsurface soils was significantly less than from corresponding surface soils. Under anaerobic conditions, floodwater DRP concentration significantly increased in>80% of calcareous surface soils and in about 40% of subsurface soils. The increase in floodwater DRP concentration was 2- to 17-fold in surface soils but only 4- to 7-fold in subsurface soils. With time of flooding, molar ratios of Ca/P and Mg/P in floodwater increased, whereas Fe/P and Mn/P decreased, suggesting that resorption and/or reprecipitation of P took place involving Fe and Mn. Results indicate that P release to floodwater under anaerobic conditions was enhanced in most calcareous soils. Surface and subsurface calcareous soils in general behaved similarly in releasing P under flooded, anaerobic conditions, with concentrations released mainly governed by initial soil P concentrations.
AGRICULTURAL WATER QUALITY IN COLD ENVIRONMENTS
SPECIAL SECTION
Core Ideas• Floodwater DRP concentration increased with time of flooding in amended and unamended soils. • Increase in floodwater DRP concentration was less under simulated snowmelt than summer flooding. • Rate of P diffusion from pore water to floodwater was less under simulated snowmelt flooding. • Gypsum reduced floodwater DRP in one soil with DRP concentrations >1 mg L −1 , but not in the other. • Woodchip biochar was ineffective in reducing P release from soils to overlying floodwater.
Increased phosphorus (P) availability under flooded, anaerobic conditions may accelerate P loss from soils to water bodies. Existing knowledge on P release to floodwater from flooded soils is limited to summer conditions and/or room temperatures. Spring snowmelt runoff, which occurs under cold temperatures with frequent freeze-thaw events, is the dominant mode of P loss from agricultural lands to water bodies in the Canadian Prairies. This research examined the effects of temperature on P dynamics under flooded conditions in a laboratory study using five agricultural soils from Manitoba, Canada. The treatments were (a) freezing for 1 wk at −20 • C, thawing and flooding at 4 ± 1 • C (frozen, cold); (b) flooding unfrozen soil at 4 ± 1 • C (unfrozen, cold); and (c) flooding unfrozen soil at 20 ± 2 • C (warm). Pore water and surface water were collected weekly over 8 wk and analyzed for dissolved reactive phosphorus (DRP), pH, calcium, magnesium, iron (Fe), and manganese (Mn). Soils under warm flooding showed enhanced P release with significantly higher DRP concentrations in pore and surface floodwater compared with cold flooding of frozen and unfrozen soils.The development of anaerobic conditions was slow under cold flooding with only a slight decrease in Eh, whereas under warm flooding Eh declined sharply, favoring reductive dissolution reactions releasing P, Fe, and Mn. Pore water and floodwater DRP concentrations were similar between frozen and unfrozen soil under cold flooding, suggesting that one freeze-thaw event prior to flooding had minimal effect on P release under simulated snowmelt conditions. Abbreviations: DAF, days after flooding; DRP, dissolved reactive phosphorus.
Phosphorus
(P) losses from flooded soils and subsequent transport
to waterways contribute to eutrophication of surface waters. This
study evaluated the effectiveness of MnO2 and a zeolite
Y amendment in reducing P release from flooded soils and explored
the underlying mechanisms controlling P release. Unamended and amended
(MnO2 or zeolite, surface-amended at 5 Mg ha–1) soil monoliths from four clayey–alkaline soils were flooded
at 22 ± 2 °C for 56 days. Soil redox potential and dissolved
reactive P (DRP), pH, and concentrations of major cations and anions
in porewater and floodwater were analyzed periodically. Soil P speciation
was simulated using Visual MINTEQ at 1, 28, and 56 days after flooding
(DAF) and P K-edge X-ray absorption near-edge structure spectroscopy
and sequential fractionation at 56 DAF. Porewater DRP increased with
DAF and correlated negatively with pe+pH and positively
with dissolved Fe. Reductive dissolution of Fe-associated P was the
dominant mechanism of flooding-induced P release. The MnO2 amendment reduced porewater DRP by 30%–50% by favoring calcium
phosphates (Ca–P) precipitation and delaying the reductive
dissolution reactions. In three soils, the zeolite amendment at some
DAF increased porewater and/or floodwater DRP through dissolution
of Ca–P and thus was not effective in reducing P release from
flooded soils.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.