The pig-to-primate model is increasingly being utilized as the final preclinical means of assessing therapeutic strategies aimed at allowing discordant xenotransplantation. We review here the world experience of both pig-to-human and pig-to-nonhuman primate organ transplantation. Eight whole organ transplants using discordant mammalian donors have been carried out in human recipients; only one patient was reported (in 1923) to have survived for longer than 72 hr. Therapeutic approaches in the experimental laboratory setting have included pharmacologic immunosuppression, antibody and/or complement depletion or inhibition, the use of pig organs transgenic for human complement regulatory proteins, and conditioning regimens aimed at inducing a state of tolerance or specific immunologic hyporesponsiveness. The greatest success to date has been obtained with methods that inhibit complement-mediated injury, either by the administration of cobra venom factor or soluble complement receptor I to the recipient (with organ survival up to 6 weeks) or by the use of donor organs transgenic for human decay-accelerating factor (with organ survival up to 2 months). The future of xenotransplantation may lie in the judicious combination of current approaches.

This conditioning regimen prevented hyperacute rejection but was ineffective in preventing the return of Ab, which was associated with the development of acute humoral rejection with features of coagulopathy. No baboon developed anti-pig Ab other than alphaGal Ab. Further modifications of the protocol directed toward suppression of production of Ab are required to successfully induce tolerance to pig organs in baboons.

Ongoing studies at our center on facilitating transplantation of discordant xenogeneic organs are focused on tolerance induction. To abrogate hyperacute rejection, we have used adsorption methods to eliminate natural anti-Gal(alpha)1-3Gal (alphaGal) antibodies from the circulation of baboons. We have analyzed data concerning antibody removal in baboons that were 1) immunologically naive, 2) receiving conventional pharmacologic immunosuppressive therapy (IS), and 3) treated with a conditioning regimen for tolerance induction. We compared the efficiency of removing alphaGal antibody 1) by perfusion of whole blood through an alphaGal affinity column (CP; n=5) with 2) perfusion of plasma (separated from cellular components by apheresis) through an alphaGal column (CPA; n=39). Our studies demonstrate that 1) CP and CPA are equally effective in removing anti-alphaGal antibody, 2) CPA is the method of choice if multiple adsorptions are required, 3) CPA in naive animals transiently affects levels of total IgG and IgM, 4) four CPAs repeated at 2-4 day intervals in association with heavy IS reduce the pool of anti-alphaGal antibody and total Ig, and 5) splenectomy and/or IS delay the return of anti-alphaGal antibody.

Anti-Galalpha1-3Gal antibodies (antialphaGal Ab) are a major barrier to clinical xenotransplantation as they are believed to initiate both hyperacute and acute humoral rejection. Extracorporeal immunoadsorption (EIA) with alphaGal oligosaccharide columns temporarily depletes antialphaGal Ab, but their return is ultimately associated with graft destruction. We therefore assessed the ability of two immunotoxins (IT) and two monoclonal antibodies (mAb) to deplete B and/or plasma cells both in vitro and in vivo in baboons, and to observe the rate of return of antialphaGal Ab following EIA. The effects of the mouse anti-human IT anti-CD22-ricin A (proportional to CD22-IT, directed against a B cell determinant) and anti-CD38-ricin A (proportional to CD38-IT, B and plasma cell determinant) and the mouse anti-human anti-CD38 mAb (proportional to CD38 mAb) and mouse/human chimeric anti-human anti-CD20 mAb (proportional to CD20 mAb, Rituximab, B cell determinant) on B and plasma cell depletion and antialphaGal Ab production were assessed both in vitro and in vivo in baboons (n = 9) that had previously undergone splenectomy. For comparison, two baboons received nonmyeloablative whole body irradiation (WBI) (300 cGy), and one received myeloablative WBI (900 cGy). Depletion of B cells was monitored by flow cytometry of blood, bone marrow (BM) and lymph nodes (LN), staining with anti-CD20 and/or anti-CD22 mAbs, and by histology of LN. EIA was carried out after the therapy and antialphaGal Ab levels were measured daily. In vitro proportional to CD22-IT inhibited protein synthesis in the human Daudi B cell line more effectively than proportional to CD38-IT. Upon differentiation of B cells into plasma cells, however, less inhibition of protein synthesis after proportional to CD22-IT treatment was observed. Depleting CD20-positive cells in vitro from a baboon spleen cell population already depleted of granulocytes, monocytes, and T cells led to a relative enrichment of CD20-negative cells, that is plasma cells, and consequently resulted in a significant increase in antialphaGal Ab production by the remaining cells, whereas depleting CD38-positive cells resulted in a significant decrease in antialphaGal Ab production. In vivo, WBI (300 or 900 cGy) resulted in 100% B cell depletion in blood and BM, > 80% depletion in LN, with substantial recovery of B cells after 21 days and only transient reduction in antialphaGal Ab after EIA. Proportional to CD22-IT depleted B cells by > 97% in blood and BM, and by 60% in LN, but a rebound of B cells was observed after 14 and 62 days in LN and blood, respectively. At 7 days, serum antialphaGal IgG and IgM Ab levels were reduced by a maximum of 40-45% followed by a rebound to levels up to 12-fold that of baseline antialphaGal Ab by day 83 in one baboon. The results obtained with proportional to CD38-IT were inconclusive. This may have been, in part, due to inadequate conjugation of the toxin. Cell coating was 100% with proportional to CD38 mAb, but no changes in antialphaGal Ab production were obs...

(1) With appropriate monitoring, EIA is an acceptably safe procedure, even in small (<10 kg) baboons. (2) Three consecutive EIAs are effective in removing >97% of Gal Ab. (3) In the majority of cases, return of Gal Ab begins within 24 h, irrespective of the immunomodulatory protocol.

The aim of this study was to deplete baboons of anti-(alpha)galactosyl (alphaGal] antibody and attempt to maintain depletion by pharmacologic immunosuppressive therapy (PI). In 12 experiments, involving nine baboons, repeated extracorporeal immunoadsorption (EIA) was carried out by plasma perfusion through immunoaffinity columns of synthetic alphaGal trisaccharide type 6. Five of the baboons were immunologically naive and four had undergone various procedures at least 6 months previously. All, however, had recovered lymphohematopoietic function and (with one exception) had levels of anti-alphaGal antibody within the normal range. Eleven protocols included continuous i.v. cyclosporine (to maintain whole blood levels of approximately 1,600 ng/ml). In addition, in ten protocols, the baboon received one or more of the following drugs: cyclophosphamide (1-20 mg/kg/day), mycophenolate mofetil (70-700 mg/ kg/day), brequinar sodium (1-12 mg/kg/day), prednisolone (1 mg/kg/day), melphalan (0.15-0.6 mg/kg/day), methylprednisolone (125 mg/day x3), and antilymphocyte globulin (ATG) (50 mg/kg/day x3). EIA was carried out on 1-9 occasions in each study and was temporarily successful in removing all antibody. When no PI was administered, antibody returned close to pre-EIA levels within 48 hr. Cyclosporine alone delayed the rate of antibody return only slightly. While EIA was continuing on a daily or alternate day schedule, antibody levels (both IgM and IgG) were maintained at 20-45% of pre-EIA levels. Once EIA was discontinued but PI maintained, IgM rose to 40-90% and IgG to 30-60% of pre-EIA levels. In vitro testing demonstrated significant cytotoxicity to pig cells at these antibody levels. We conclude that i) EIA utilizing columns of alphaGal trisaccharide is successful in temporarily depleting baboons of anti-alphaGal antibody, but ii) none of the PI regimens tested suppressed antibody production to levels which would be expected to prevent antibody-mediated rejection of pig xenografts. Additional strategies will therefore be required if xenotransplantation is to become a clinical reality.

EU regulations call for the use of alternative methods to animal testing. During the last decade, an increasing number of alternative approaches have been formally adopted. In parallel, new 3Rs-relevant technologies and mechanistic approaches have increasingly contributed to hazard identification and risk assessment evolution. In this changing landscape, an EPAA meeting reviewed the challenges that different industry sectors face in the implementation of alternative methods following a science-driven approach. Although clear progress was acknowledged in animal testing reduction and refinement thanks to an integration of scientifically robust approaches, the following challenges were identified: i) further characterization of toxicity pathways; ii) development of assays covering current scientific gaps, iii) better characterization of links between in vitro readouts and outcome in the target species; iv) better definition of alternative method applicability domains, and v) appropriate implementation of the available approaches. For areas having regulatory adopted alternative methods (e.g., vaccine batch testing), harmonised acceptance across geographical regions was considered critical for broader application. Overall, the main constraints to the application of non-animal alternatives are the still existing gaps in scientific knowledge and technological limitations. The science-driven identification of most appropriate methods is key for furthering a multi-sectorial decrease in animal testing.

Ten piglets, 7 to 16 weeks old, were partially thymectomised and 1 to 4 cm3 of minced thymic fragments autografted under the renal capsule. They were sacrificed, respectively, after 2, 4, 6, 8, 12, and 20 weeks. After 2 weeks, irregular whitish zones are present under the renal capsule. They were composed principally of two cell types: the first type was characterized by small round basophilic nuclei and little cytoplasm typical of lymphocytes; the second cell type had larger ovoid nuclei and a large vacuolised cytoplasm. Each cell type could be found in separate lobules or mixed in variable proportion in the same structure. The thymic autografts grew to form a layer up to 4 mm thick after 20 weeks. In the meantime, at the beginning of 4th week, the lobular structure became well organized with the cell type presenting large nuclei and cytoplasm being restricted to the center of the lobules while lymphocytes composed a peripheral layer. Hassal corpuscles (HC) appeared in the center of the lobules. Immunohistochemical labeling with anti‐cytokeratin mono‐ and poly‐ clonal Ab and with anti‐neurophysin polyclonal Ab displayed all the characteristics of normal functional thymic microenvironment. It is proposed that this novel experimental preparation ending up as a neo‐organ (thymo‐kidney) be used for xenotransplantation in an attempt to produce specific xenotolerance.