Purpose: Belief is a major aspect of every human being, especially in critical situations. We aimed to investigate if physicians think that religion should be implemented in the communication and/or management of the critical patient. We assessed their opinion about the need to have spiritual figures among the healthcare team in the Intensive Care Unit (ICU). Methods: An anonymous 30-question survey was conducted over a period of 7 months among health care providers in 174 different institutions around 40 different countries. The Questionnaire addressed religion and how it may affect the management and/or interaction with patients. Specifically, we inquired if the presence of a religious figure (e.g. Rabbi, Priest/Pastor, Imam, etc.) would enhance the communication and/or management of the patients. Results: Of the 10,106 surveys that were submitted, 30.6% (n=3092) were physicians, 22.4% (n=2262) were nurses, and the rest were medical students and other health care providers. The opinions on the impact on managing patients and communicating with them and their families in the presence of a spiritual authority, such as a Pastor, Priest, Rabbi, Imam or any other religious figure, as part of the ICU team, revealed that 47.9% (n=1480) of physicians thought it could be beneficial, 14% (n=433) said that it could be harmful, and 36.6% (n=1131) affirmed no impact. Regarding nurses, 51.4% (n=1163) indicated that it is beneficial, 10.1% (n=228) indicated that it is harmful, and 35.6% (n=806) think there is no impact. Of the physicians, 20.3% (n=628) of practicing members of a religion, 16.7% (n=519) of those who are believers but not practicing, 7.8% (n=242) of those spiritual but not religious, 2.1% (n=65) of those who do not believe in god or gods, consider that religious figures incorporated in the ICU team can improve patient outcome. While 26.0% (n=557) of nurses who are practicing members, 20.3% (n=435) of those who are believers but not practicing, and only 1% (n=116) of the other two categories (the spiritual but not religious and the non-believers) share the same opinion, p <0.001. Conclusions: One in every two physicians/nurses in this study considered spiritual authorities, as part of the ICU team, beneficial in managing the patients and communicating with them and their families. We also found a correlation between the religious practice of the physicians/nurses and their opinion about its impact on the care of the patients. Physicians who are committed to a religious practice, tend to state that this could be beneficial; while nurses who are spiritual but not religious indicated no impact on the management.
Purpose: While caring for patients, it is important to recognize more than just the apparent physical symptoms. Their emotional well-being, level of comfort, and spiritual concerns are relevant and should be taken into consideration. We aimed to identify if a greater commitment to spiritual belief systems by healthcare providers could have an effect on the patient care they provided. Methods: The Ethics in Intensive Care Study (ETHICS) was conducted in multiple centers all over the world utilizing a confidential survey. Questions were related to personal opinions on ethical issues, including personal beliefs, and patient care. We hypothesized that the personal beliefs of the healthcare providers should not affect the quality of care provided. Pearson’s correlation was used to ascertain statistical significance. Results: A total of 9,720 healthcare providers rated their level of spirituality from 1 (least) to 10 (greatest), and answered whether their beliefs affected their patient care. The majority of the people surveyed (65.6%; n=6,378) assessed themselves between 5 and 8 out of 10. In each individual level, most physicians felt patient care was not affected. However, on closer inspection and analysis, an interesting trend emerged. Only 11.4% (n=45) of those who rated themselves in level 1 of spirituality (n=394) stated their patient care was affected by their personal beliefs. Of people in level 5 (n=1,300), 13.3% (n=173) felt their beliefs affect the quality of care provided, and surprisingly, that number increased to 21.4% (n=193) among those healthcare provider rated in level 10 (n=899) [ p <0.001, Pearson’s R correlation 0.94]. Conclusions: A significant number of physicians identify themselves as religious, whether by belief in God, or based on a level of spirituality. We found a strong correlation between the level of spirituality a provider feels and the perception of how much his/her patient care is affected. We are not aware if this translates into real differences in patient care.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
customersupport@researchsolutions.com
10624 S. Eastern Ave., Ste. A-614
Henderson, NV 89052, USA
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Copyright © 2024 scite LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with 💙 for researchers
Part of the Research Solutions Family.