Metaphysics often has an important role in deciding ethical questions. Specifically, in the realm of bioethics, metaphysical questions such as the nature of persons, diseases, and properties in general can be crucial to determining what is right or wrong. In this article, I tie together various metaphysical themes that recur throughout the rest of the issue: rationality as an element of human nature, ontological classifications, and kinds of action. I will explain that each has ethical implications. Actions that contravene reason will be morally problematic, whereas our classification of illnesses will have important implications for how we ought to respond to ill persons. Metaphysical questions appear, or are at least suggested, in each article, pointing to the need for metaphysics in answering bioethical questions.
No abstract
Following the work of MacIntyre, I call for a particularized approach to ethics. I do not base my argument on concrete situations, but rather, on the way virtue works. Following Aristotle's account, I contend that most people's conception of virtue, even abstracted from particular situations, misses something key: the ways of attaining virtue can be vastly different, and even diametrically opposed, for different people. This difference exists even without differences in external factors. People struggling with divergent vices will need to practice virtue in divergent ways. Therefore, I contend that we need to particularize the way we view the attainment of virtue, not just because each person is in a different situation or context, but because not every person approaches virtue from the same vice. I. INTRODUCTION: WHY PARTICULARIZE ETHICS?In Ethics in the Conflicts of Modernity, MacIntyre advocates a particularized approach to ethics. He critiques vast generalizations often made in ethics, remarking that they overlook diverse cultural, personal, and circumstantial factors, which influence both what is ethical and how one might discover what is ethical. 1 He discusses various narratives of how a human being may flourish, adding, 'What I emphasized then were differences that result from the particularities of the different cultures in which those lives lived out.' He continues that the distinctive feature among different lives is the individuality of each agent's desires and practical reasoning. He says, 'For it is one of the characteristics of a good practical reasoner to be able to identify the relevant particularities of her or his situation, what it is on occasion about the situation that makes it difficult to apply generalizations and dangerous to rely on precedents.' 2 Ethics must be particular because what constitutes flourishing will vary widely from person to person.Similarly, Foucault observes that actions must be considered, not only in light of circumstances, but also in light of one's intentions and the end of the action. He prescribes reflection upon one's own actions and consideration of the ends relevant to those actions, offering the example, 'When we argue with someone it is in order to convey a truth to him. So if I find myself again in similar situations, I must recall these different ends so that from then on my actions will be adapted to them.' 3 Actions must be evaluated in light of their ends, as well as in light of their effect upon others in the proximity and additional circumstantial factors.Aristotle further validates particularity in ethics, because statements about more particular acts are truer than generalizations. While he recognizes the value of certain ethical V C 2018 Trustees for Roman Catholic Purposes Registered.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
customersupport@researchsolutions.com
10624 S. Eastern Ave., Ste. A-614
Henderson, NV 89052, USA
Copyright © 2024 scite LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with 💙 for researchers
Part of the Research Solutions Family.