“…Recently, shadow education has witnessed growing recognition from researchers, educators, and policymakers owing to its influential implications for social equality, economic growth, and the operation of formal education systems (Entrich, 2021 ). This is evidenced by its increasing presence not only in books (e.g., Bray & Lykins, 2012 ; Bray et al, 2020a , 2020b ; Bray, 2021a ; Entrich, 2018a , 2018b ; Kim & Jung, 2019 ) but also in special issues in scholarly journals, such as Asia Pacific Education Review (Bray & Lee, 2010 ), East China Normal University Review of Education (Zhang & Bray, 2019 ), European Journal of Education (Gordon Györi, 2020 ), and Orbis Scholae (Šťastný & Kobakhidze, 2020 ).…”