Working with layers: The governance and regulation of healthcare quality in an institutionally layered system

Abstract

Institutional arrangements used to steer public policies have increasingly become layered. Inspired by the literature on institutional layering and institutional work, this paper aims to make a contribution to our understanding of institutional layering. We do so by studying an interesting case of layering: the Dutch hospital sector. We focus on the actors responsible for the internal governance (Board of Directors and Supervisory Boards) and the external regulation (the Healthcare Inspectorate) of hospitals. In the paper, we explore the institutional work of these actors, more specifically how institutional work results from and is influenced by institutional layering and how this in turn influences the institutional makeup of both healthcare organizations and their institutional context. Our approach allowed us to see that layering changes the activities of actors in the public sector, can be used to strengthen one’s position but also presents actors with new struggles, which they in turn can try to overcome by relating and using the institutionally layered context. Layering and institutional work are therefore in continuous interaction. Combining institutional layering with a focus on the lived experiences of actors and their institutional work makes it possible to move into the layered arrangement and better understand its consequences.

Exploring challenges in quality and safety work in nursing homes and home care – a case study as basis for theory development

“…Similar results were reported in a previous study of Norwegian nursing homes and home care services [22]. Furthermore, these findings are in line with research of van de Bovenkamp et al [23] that uses institutional work when describing how managers both shape and are shaped by their organizational contexts. The increased external pressure reported by participants in our study made it harder for them to strengthen engagement and culture for working on quality and safety, and to maintain this collective effort involving both managers and employees.…”

Foxes and Lions: How Institutional Leaders Keep Organisational Integrity and Introduce Change

“…In the 1990s came the next shift, this time towards network-based, collaborative approaches to governance. Each of the logic sediments in organisational structures influences the way new organisational practices and identities are perceived (van de Bovenkamp, Stoopendaal, & Bal, 2017). Whenever projective agency is used to create innovative solutions according to a new logic, there is a risk that old, deeper-rooted logic prevails, and what was supposed to be qualitatively different turns out to be an old thing in a new wrapping.…”

The Punjab Revenue Authority: Meeting the challenges of a new institution

“…Creating a new institution could, thus, be viewed as offering a point for a critical juncture. According to Thelen's (2009) work on institutional change, the challenge for institutional designers becomes that of how to "layer" the new structure on existing ones and work within the prevailing institutional framework to pursue different goals (see also Bick, 2016;van de Bovenkamp, Stoopendaal, & Bal, 2017).…”