Working for Free in the VIP

Abstract

Why do workers participate in their own exploitation? This article moves beyond the situational production of consent that has dominated studies of the labor process and outlines the relational production of labor’s surplus value. Using a case of unpaid women who perform valuable work for VIP nightclubs, I present ethnographic data on the VIP party circuit from New York, the Hamptons, Miami, and Cannes, as well as 84 interviews with party organizers and guests. Party promoters, mostly male brokers, appropriate surplus value from women in four stages: recruitment, mobilization, performance, and control. Relational work between promoters and women, cemented by gifts and strategic intimacies, frames women’s labor as leisure and friendship, and boundary work legitimizes women’s work as distinct from sexual labor. When boundaries, media, and meanings of relationships do not appropriately align, as in relational mismatches, women experience the VIP party less as leisure and more as work, and they are less likely to participate. My findings embed the labor process in a relational infrastructure and hold insights for explaining why people work for free in culture and technology sectors of the post-Fordist economy.

“There’s No Way That You Get Paid to Do the Arts”: Unpaid Labour Across the Cultural and Creative Life Course

“…In this article, we build on existing research (Mears, 2015; Randle et al, 2015; Siebert and Wilson, 2013; Umney and Kretsos, 2013), using the CCIs to engage with broader questions about contemporary work. Specifically, we explore precariousness and insecurity in the CCIs by demonstrating how experiences of unpaid labour differ according to people’s social class, age, and career stage.…”

The Professionalization of Action Sports: Mapping Trends and Future Directions

“…With athletes being 'used' to build relationships between the brand and the products of companies, and to contribute in developing relationships between the companies, brands and consumers, they are playing an important role in producing what has been coined as 'relational labour ' (e.g. Baym 2015;Mears 2015). Indeed, part of the job is to generate and foster interactions with fans-as-followers through the deployment of multiple strategies, a process in which social media technologies play a central role.…”

Affect & Labor

“…Regardless of these critiques, the theory of emotional labor remains extremely influential and has inspired a series of related concepts that capture different aspects of the interactive work involved in service occupations, such as body labor (Kang, 2003), relational labor (Mears, 2015;Zelizer, 2005a;), bridgework (Otis, 2016), or aesthetic labor (Warhust and Nickson, 2007). Among these, the framework of intimate labor defines "a continuum of service and caring labor, from high-end nursing to low-end housekeeping, and includes sex, domestic, and care work" (Boris and Parreñas, 2010, p. 2).…”

“…A significant characteristic of labor in advanced capitalism is the increasing exercise of autonomy and individuality by workers, one way in which work is made highly meaningful and central to identity while simultaneously diminishing expectations of stability and proper compensation (Gregg, 2011;Pugh, 2015;Tokumitsu, 2015). Consent to participate in unequal labor exchanges is based on different affective grounds: from social ties, gifts, and intimacy (Mears, 2015) to workers' construction of identities as "caring selves" (Stacey, 2011) or norms of reciprocity with clients (Sherman, 2007).…”