Work‐based assessment: qualitative perspectives of novice nutrition and dietetics educators

Abstract

Background The assessment of competence for health professionals including nutrition and dietetics professionals in work-based settings is challenging. The present study aimed to explore the experiences of educators involved in the assessment of nutrition and dietetics students in the practice setting and to identify barriers and enablers to effective assessment. Methods A qualitative research approach using in-depth interviews was employed with a convenience sample of inexperienced dietitian assessors. Interviews explored assessment practices and challenges. Data were analysed using a thematic approach within a phenomenological framework. Twelve relatively inexperienced practice educators were purposefully sampled to take part in the present study. Results Three themes emerged from these data. (i) Student learning and thus assessment is hindered by a number of barriers, including workload demands and case-mix. Some workplaces are challenged to provide appropriate learning opportunities and environment. Adequate support for placement educators from the university, managers and their peers and planning are enablers to effective assessment. (ii) The role of the assessor and their relationship with students impacts on competence assessment. (iii) There is a lack of clarity in the tasks and responsibilities of competency-based assessment. Conclusions The present study provides perspectives on barriers and enablers to effective assessment. It highlights the importance of reflective practice and feedback in assessment practices that are synonymous with evidence from other disciplines, which can be used to better support a work-based competency assessment of student performance.

Clinical educators’ skills and qualities in allied health: a systematic review

“…Students entering clinical placements plunge from the structured and familiar academic environment into the busy, demanding and often stressful clinical setting. Clinical placement learning is complex, with relationship building with peers and staff underpinning the creation of professional identity . These sociocultural elements of practice shape development and are essential to the advancement of clinical and professional skills.…”

Evaluation of assessment in the context of work‐based learning: Qualitative perspectives of new graduates

“…The instrumental role of the supervisor or clinical educator for facilitating student learning through assessment was also highlighted. The qualities of an effective supervisor have been articulated and the need to build the capacity of dietitian assessors to implement assessment recently highlighted …”

Growing professional competence in nutrition and dietetics

“…Many competency‐based assessment approaches are centred on individual competency elements or performance criteria, with the link to the whole picture of competence left unclear. Dietetic assessors have described their lack of faith in a ‘tick‐box’ approach to competency‐based assessment, acknowledging the risks of failing to see competence as being something more than just the sum of its parts …”

“…In Australia, a diverse range of approaches has been used to develop competency standards for dietitians . Despite their differences, all these approaches have incorporated the views of experts as to what constitutes ‘competence’ notwithstanding the fact that the profession has expressed difficulties in defining competence . Although patients' needs seem to have been a driver for the competency‐based education movement, patients themselves have had little say in the development of standards of performance.…”