Women social entrepreneurs in a Muslim society: how to manage patriarchy and spouses

Abstract

Purpose This study aims to investigate how women social entrepreneurs in Indonesia use various behaviors to address challenges to their leadership authority created by socioreligious patriarchal norms in this Muslim society. Design/methodology/approach An exploratory study of six Muslim women social entrepreneurs was conducted using multiround, semistructured interviews in a contrast sample of three women who work with their husbands and three women who work without their husband’s involvement. Findings The study identifies a variety of leadership behaviors that women entrepreneurs use to mitigate the constraining impact of strong patriarchal religious gender norms. Observations revealed surprisingly effective micro adjustments often based on relationship-specific private negotiations between the entrepreneurs and their husbands. Research limitations/implications Future research focused on the husbands’ perspectives and behaviors, as well as extensions to other patriarchal religions and societies, are encouraged. Practical implications Recognition of the crucial role of spousal relationships suggests the need for more holistic approaches to support women social entrepreneurship, e.g. by integrating husbands into related outreach programs. Social implications Religious gender stereotypes such as the stronger altruistic orientation of women can help counteract, to a degree, Muslim patriarchal norms when women lead social enterprises. Leadership of social enterprises by women promises to promote more gender equality over time, even if associated private and relationship-specific accommodations are not intended to challenge religious gender norms. Originality/value This study contributes to emerging research on the crucial role of spousal relationships for women’s entrepreneurship and the impact of private micro arrangements between spouses to mitigate the constraining impact of Muslim gender norms. Muslim women entrepreneurs approved of the religious gender norms that constrained them, in contrast to the more “feminist” perspectives common in women entrepreneurs in more secular and Christianity-dominated western societies.

Social Entrepreneurship and Social Capital: A Review of Impact Research

“…Core societal problems are analyzed using the networks, values, and trust approach to building SEs. Here, the main themes analyzed are: (a) poverty [104][105][106][107]; (b) social change (divisions /cohesion/inclusion/solidarity) [108][109][110][111][112]; (c) human empowerment [113]; including women entrepreneurship [114][115][116] and indigenous entrepreneurship [117]; (d) community development [118][119][120][121][122][123][124][125][126][127][128][129][130][131][132][133]; (e) growth and wellbeing [134][135][136]; and (f) public goods such as water, electricity, waste management, safety, health, food, and so on [137][138][139][140][141][142][143][144][145][146][147][148].…”

Identity Construction of Pakistani Female Entrepreneurs in Religious Framework: An Interplay of Sociocultural and Religious Factors

“…Women’s leadership, in particular, clashes with even more specific standards of male-spousal leadership for married women. The difficulties that follow frequently have an impact on a woman’s career and personal life (Ummiroh et al, 2022).…”

Islamic Social Entrepreneurship Model Of Business Women In Pandemic Era: Evidence From Indonesia

“…In the concept of social entrepreneurship, an important role is played by entrepreneurial motivation (Ruiz-Rosa et al, 2020). While the main goal of entrepreneurship in general is to make a profit, the main goal of social and environmental entrepreneurship is to solve social and environmental problems (Ummiroh, Ruhul, Schawab Andreas, 2020) Additionally, in this program women entrepreneurs are assisted to obtain financing from external parties based on sharia values. This financing will certainly support them to keep existing and surviving in the midst of competition.…”