Windthrow Detection in European Forests with Very High-Resolution Optical Data

Abstract

With climate change, extreme storms are expected to occur more frequently. These storms can cause severe forest damage, provoking direct and indirect economic losses for forestry. To minimize economic losses, the windthrow areas need to be detected fast to prevent subsequent biotic damage, for example, related to beetle infestations. Remote sensing is an efficient tool with high potential to cost-efficiently map large storm affected regions. Storm Niklas hit South Germany in March 2015 and caused widespread forest cover loss. We present a two-step change detection approach applying commercial very high-resolution optical Earth Observation data to spot forest damage. First, an object-based bi-temporal change analysis is carried out to identify windthrow areas larger than 0.5 ha. For this purpose, a supervised Random Forest classifier is used, including a semi-automatic feature selection procedure; for image segmentation, the large-scale mean shift algorithm was chosen. Input features include spectral characteristics, texture, vegetation indices, layer combinations and spectral transformations. A hybrid-change detection approach at pixel-level subsequently identifies small groups of fallen trees, combining the most important features of the previous processing step with Spectral Angle Mapper and Multivariate Alteration Detection. The methodology was evaluated on two test sites in Bavaria with RapidEye data at 5 m pixel resolution. The results regarding windthrow areas larger than 0.5 ha were validated with reference data from field visits and acquired through orthophoto interpretation. For the two test sites, the novel object-based change detection approach identified over 90% of the windthrow areas (≥0.5 ha). The red edge channel was the most important for windthrow identification. Accuracy levels of the change detection at tree level could not be calculated, as it was not possible to collect field data for single trees, nor was it possible to perform an orthophoto validation. Nevertheless, the plausibility and applicability of the pixel-based approach is demonstrated on a second test site.

Optimal Input Features for Tree Species Classification in Central Europe Based on Multi-Temporal Sentinel-2 Data

“…Another benefit is the computation of importance measures which can be used for the evaluation of the input data and subsequent feature reduction. In this study, a recursive feature selection process using the 'Mean decrease in Accuracy' (MDA) was applied similarly to other studies [18,43,44]. More information about the algorithm and its advantages, such as the importance measure for the input variables and the integrated bootstrapping, can be found in the literature [16,41,45,46].…”

Rapid Detection of Windthrows Using Sentinel-1 C-Band SAR Data

“…This evaluation was performed in a manner similar to the object-based method of Einzmann et al [11]. We generated a contingency table for the two classes "windthrow" and "no windthrow".…”

Forecasting wind gusts in winter storms using a calibrated convection‐permitting ensemble

“…According to the SSI, the most severe storm of the 2011–2016 period by far is Niklas on March 31, 2015 (Table ), which caused widespread loss of forest cover in southern Germany (Einzmann et al. , ). Niklas is one of the most severe storms over Germany in records from the DWD surface network and reaches rank 14 since the 1970s in SSI corrected for the number of stations (see Figure S3 in File S1).…”