Why do people not learn from flood disasters? Evidence from Vietnam’s northwestern mountains

Abstract

This article explores how the causes and impacts of a flood event as perceived by local people shape immediate responses and future mitigation efforts in mountainous northwest Vietnam. Local flood perception is contrasted with scientific perspectives to determine whether a singular flood event will trigger adjustments in mitigation strategies in an otherwise rarely flood-affected area. We present findings from interdisciplinary research drawing on both socioeconomic and biophysical data. Evidence suggests that individual farmers' willingness to engage in flood mitigation is curbed by the common perception that flooding is caused by the interplay of a bundle of external factors, with climatic factors and water management failures being the most prominent ones. Most farmers did not link the severity of flooding to existing land use systems, thus underlining the lack of a sense of personal responsibility among farmers for flood mitigation measures. We conclude that local governments cannot depend on there being a sufficient degree of intrinsic motivation among farmers to make them implement soil conservation techniques to mitigate future flooding. Policy makers will need to design measures to raise farmers' awareness of the complex interplay between land use and hydrology and to enhance collective action in soil 123Nat Hazards (2012) 62:221-241 DOI 10.1007 conservation by providing appropriate incentives and implementing coherent long-term strategies.

The double-edged sword of learning from disasters: Mortality in the Tohoku tsunami

“…Brody et al (2009) point toward improvements in local flood mitigation policies after historical flood events in Florida. Conversely, very little beneficial learning seems to take place where disasters are rare events (Schad et al, 2012) or happen only at the very local level (Voss and Wagner, 2010).…”

Improved Sustainable Aquaculture Systems for Small-Scale Farmers in Northern Vietnam

“…In order to avoid the negative effects of eroded particles coming from surrounding upland fields and pesticides from neighboring paddy fields, our study ponds, using the modified management system, were isolated from external water flows. The dikes used needed to be strengthened against flooding caused by heavy rains (Schad et al 2012), and cracks and macro pores in the dikes had to be sealed. Ponds were equipped with proper pipes for controlling inflows and outflows, with the outlet pipe situated at the deepest point in the pond so that the water could be completely drained for harvests and drying purposes.…”

Modelling the fate of pesticides in paddy rice-fish pond farming systems in northern Vietnam

“…Each household usually cultivates one to several paddy rice fields and at least one fish pond. Detailed information about the study area can be found in Lamers et al ., Schad et al . and Anyusheva et al …”