Why did the industrial diet triumph? The massification of dairy consumption in Spain, 1965–90

Abstract

The rise of a mass, agri‐industrial diet after the Second World War was crucial for the culmination of the nutritional transition that western countries had been involved in since the second half of the nineteenth century—but why did the industrial diet triumph? This article takes the massification of dairy consumption in Spain 1965–90 as a study case. Using a newly constructed database and qualitative material within an evolutionary socio‐economic framework, the article reaches two conclusions. First, the massification of dairy consumption was linked to most households’ transition to a softer budget constraint, which was driven mainly by increasing household incomes (and only secondarily by consumer price reductions caused by food industrialization). Second, the reason why the softening of the budget constraint played such a major role was that it was joined by a substantial increase in consumer trust in dairy products, which in turn resulted from industrial standardization. The article is in line with recent work that underlines the dietary change brought about by food industrialization, but questions whether the latter's major contribution was of a quantitative, price‐related nature and suggests that more attention should be paid to the qualitative, preferences‐related dimension.

El campo semántico del relevo generacional en el sector ganadero de leche: obstáculos y facilitadores

“…A pesar del crecimiento exponencial de la producción de leche, especialmente a partir del fin de las cuotas en el 2015, los últimos años han estado marcados por una profunda crisis de precios de la leche que ha puesto en importantes dificultades la continuidad de muchas explotaciones (Barbeta-Viñas y Requena-i-Mora, 2022 y 2023; Díaz Yúbero, 2016). Esta cuestión ha estado menos vinculada con la demanda y el consumo de leche, cuyas preferencias sí han influido históricamente sobre la elección de tipos de leche determinados (Collantes, 2019), que con la incorporación de la mayoría de granjas lecheras a la ganadería de mercado, con un fuerte control por parte de la industria lechera y en un contexto altamente competitivo, especializado y globalizado (Bonanno, Russo y Menapace, 2018; Collantes, 2016). El precio de la leche cruda ha estado así sujeto a una fuerte volatilidad a la baja, dificultando las previsiones y contratiempos de los ganaderos (O'Connor, Bergmann y Keane, 2015;Glover, 2015).…”

Distributing legitimacy: the politics of milk in post-World War II Venezuela

“…The rumors, though false, highlight how the distribution of food, particularly highly perishable food such as fluid milk, generally involves a complicated balancing act between legitimacy, trust, and price. 15 An organization, whether public or private, that can provide wider, more affordable, or more certain access to food can gain or enhance its institutional legitimacy. Failure to do so, as the literature on the moral economy of food has repeatedly shown, can lead to mass rejection of the legitimacy of entire classes of organization-e.g., "middlemen," grain speculators, chain stores, local and national governments.…”

From organized to disorganized capitalism? Market versus nonmarket coordination in Spain's dairy chain

“…The massification of dairy consumption was made possible by the rapid increase in household incomes (which resulted from rapid economic growth and a decrease in social inequality) and the spread of prodairy nutritional advice by physicians and the state and also by the industrialization of the production chain. The greater part of the consumption boom was met by domestic production (Figure ), and the availability of processed milks contributed to improving consumer trust at a time when raw milk was suffering from serious quality problems in many parts of the country (Collantes, ; Collantes, ; Domínguez, and Langreo, ).…”