When Market Information Constitutes Fields: Sensemaking of Markets in the Commercial Music Industry

Abstract

In this paper we outline a key mechanism through which organizational fields are constituted. We suggest that in competitive fields, the market serves as a magnet around which groups of actors consolidate, and that cognition of markets occurs through the creation, distribution, and interpretation of a web of information about the “market.” To illustrate our theory, we present a case study of the Billboard music chart from the commercial music industry to show that changes in either scope, methodology, or political tone with which market information is presented can provide a major jolt to the participants' understanding of their field.

Developing the organization's sensemaking capability: Precursor to an adaptive strategic marketing response

“…Previous examinations of sensemaking have sought to argue its existence within organizations (Anand & Peterson, 2000;Bogner & Barr, 2000;Gioia & Thomas, 1996) with limited empirical evidence confirming its relationship with organiza tional performance (Thomas et al, 1993). Only recently have researchers begun to examine the role of sensemaking in new product (Akgun, Lynn, & Yilmaz, 2006) and interfirm outcomes (Johnson, Sohi, & Grewal, 2004).…”

The Art of Representation: How Audience-specific Reputations Affect Success in the Contemporary Art Field

“…A commonly held view is that reputation involves "being known for something" (Jensen & Roy, 2008;Lange et al, 2011) and is based on an actor's accomplishments and history (Barron & Rolfe, 2012;Weigelt & Camerer, 1988). 1 Previous studies that have examined the external signals of reputation (Anand & Peterson, 2000;Carter et al, 1998;Ebbers & Wijnberg, 2012;Philippe & Durand, 2011) suggest that reputation reduces uncertainty about an actor's future behavior, which enables evaluators (i.e., an audience) to assess actors (Spence, 1973). A positive reputation is beneficial because it reduces uncertainty and provides reassurance of an actor's value.…”

Building the iron cage: institutional creation work in the context of competing proto-institutions

“…A great deal of work in the last two decades has shown that institutional entrepreneurs may arise to question institutional arrangements (DiMaggio, 1988), resisting them strategically (Oliver, 1991;Ang & Cummings, 1997), disrupting and deinstitutionalizing them (Ahmadjian & Robinson, 2001;Oliver, 1992), and reconstructing them to suit the desires of different actors (Anand & Peterson, 2000;Hargadon & Douglas, 2001;Zilber, 2002).…”