What Scientific Issues in Life Cycle Assessment Applied to Waste and Biomass Valorization? Editorial

Abstract

International audienceWhereas Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) is more and more used for assessing the environmental load of waste management systems and of biomass production and valorization systems, various scientific issues are still to be dealt with. The purpose of this paper is to enlighten these scientific issues and to describe the current attempt to overcome them. The method used has been to go through the steps of the LCA standardized framework (ISO 14040) and to outline at each step the points that could be improved and still deserve research efforts. The various identified issues are: in step 1 (goal and scope), the choice of attributional/consequential modelling, the difficult choice of the functional unit due to the highly multi-functional nature of such systems, the allocation choices and the need for spatial differentiation; in step 2 (inventory), the thorny issue of modelling such complex systems and properly estimating field emissions; in step 3 (impact assessment), the lack of appropriate impacts (such as odours) in current LCA impact categories; in step 4 (interpretation and use), research efforts are needed to understand and facilitate the way actors take over and use LCA multi-criteria results. A transversal issue, i.e. uncertainty characterization and reduction, is also analyzed. These various scientific bottlenecks are currently under study; some are handled by this "Waste and Biomass Valorization" special topic, which includes a selection of papers presented in 2011 at the Ecotech&Tools conference (Montpellier, France)

Life-Cycle Assessment of Microwave-Assisted Pectin Extraction at Pilot Scale

“…LCA is a popular technique to quantify the environmental impacts of products and processes taking into consideration all life-cycle stages involved: obtention of raw materials, manufacturing, transportation, use, and end of life. LCA is also becoming widely used to assess environmental impacts of waste management and waste valorization. , Due to the increasing interest in the use of LCAs to analyze environmental impacts, this technique has been standardized by the International Organization for Standardization, , which divides the LCA procedure into four main phases: definition of the goal and scope, life-cycle inventory, life-cycle impact assessment, and interpretation. These four LCA phases have been applied in this paper to study the environmental impacts of thermal and microwave extraction of pectin from citrus peel.…”

Circular Economy Applied to Organic Residues and Wastewater: Research Challenges

“…Efforts to evaluate processes and process chains in a circular bioeconomy run up against several difficulties, partly due to the existing evaluation methodologies and partly due to the lack of data [28,29]. The first difficulty arises from the constructs of 'sustainability' and 'circularity' used to define bioeconomy.…”

Methodological issues in comparative life cycle assessment: treatment options for empty fruit bunches in a palm oil system

“…4 of Lim and Lee (2011)) b Stichnothe and Schuchardt (2010) assumed that biogas was used to replace the fuel for starting a boiler (internal use), while Hansen et al (2012) assumed that biogas was used for electricity production to supply the national grid (external use) conversion unit to create a certain product. The latter process provides both a waste treatment function and a function intending to produce a certain product (Bellon-Maurel et al 2013). In the context of defining a system boundary, a waste stream is conventionally assumed to be free of environmental burden.…”