Western Conservation Theory and the Asian Context: The Different Roots of Conservation

Kwanda, Timoticin

doi:10.31124/advance.8867111.v1

Cited by 5 publications

(11 citation statements)

References 4 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…This multi-sensory discussion supports the development of ways of thinking about the management and conservation of cultural heritage that are more value, environmental, and socialoriented (Amin and Adu-Ampong 2016; Andreu 2017) as well as non-physical elements (Smith 2006), which are considered to represent more of the public's assessment of cultural heritage areas, especially in Asian countries (S. Chung 2016;Kwanda 2009;Torre 2002;Wells 2010). As elsewhere expressed by Smith (2006), this is consistent with the paradigm shift in cultural heritage conservation, as previous models and discussions have been centered on the physical (tangible) and have yet to consider significant non-physical (intangible) aspects (Jigyasu 1998;Gutschow and Weiler 2017;Taylor and Lennon 2012).…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 64%

“…In Asia, the model for preserving cultural heritage areas has shifted from an object-based approach to an inclusive subject-based approach focusing on non-physical heritage (Kwanda 2009). Multi-sensory is considered as part of nonphysical heritage, which refers to the quality of individual perception, which is a new and important thought in describing, appreciating and assessing urban cultural heritage areas (Martokusumo et al 2019).…”

Section: Multi-sensory In the Conservation Of Cultural Heritage Areasmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…Creating this humane cultural heritage environment aims to respond the model of cultural heritage management and conservation that pays little attention to the essential dimensions of humans as users with all of their sensors (Orbasli 2000;Nasser 2003). Managing cultural heritage areas based on subject appreciation has been acknowledged as a new understanding in Asia within the last decades (Kwanda 2009). Before that, experts still determined the significance of heritage, indicating that heritage management extends beyond the community to which it belongs (Gutschow and Weiler 2017;Walter 2020).…”

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

See 2 more Smart Citations

Multi-sensori dalam konsepsi tempat pada lingkungan cagar budaya perkotaan

Septianto,

Djimantoro,

Noviandri

et al. 2023

ARTEKS J. Tek. Arsit.

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Multi-sensori berpengaruh dalam mengenali sebuah tempat lebih baik. Proses mengenali tersebut perlu didukung oleh konsepsi tempat yang tidak dibatasi oleh aspek fisik saja. Pemahaman ini berlawanan dengan paradigma yang umum terjadi dalam pemahaman dan model pelestarian kawasan cagar budaya yang masih terbatas pada peningkatan kualitas fisik berdasarkan indra visual. Artikel ini mendiskusikan peran dan potensi multi-sensori dalam memahami konsepsi tempat yang bermanfaat pada pelestarian kawasan cagar budaya perkotaan. Penelitian ini menggunakan pengumpulan data dari studi kepustakaan dan pengamatan lapangan kawasan cagar budaya sekitar Gedung Sate kota Bandung. Hasil penelitian menunjukkan bahwa persepsi multi-sensori berperan serta berpotensi untuk mempermudah proses pembacaan dan merasakan tempat oleh individu. Diskusi ini membuka wacana baru untuk mengintegrasikan aspek non fisik berbasis persepsi subjek dalam diskusi kawasan cagar budaya perkotaan.

show abstract

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 64%

Section: Multi-sensory In the Conservation Of Cultural Heritage Areasmentioning

confidence: 99%

Section: Introductionmentioning

confidence: 99%

See 1 more Smart Citation

Multi-sensori dalam konsepsi tempat pada lingkungan cagar budaya perkotaan

Septianto,

Djimantoro,

Noviandri

et al. 2023

ARTEKS J. Tek. Arsit.

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…The classical conservation theory sees that the original material is the most essential and foremost witness to the history of the building (Kwanda, 2013). Over time, this classical view has shifted into a contemporary conservation view, marked by its concerns for humans as the main focus.…”

Section: Conservation Principlesmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…It considers humans who lived at that time as the ones who give meaning, value, and function, and determine what is called a legacy (Loulanski, 2006). In their paper, Kwanda (2013) stated that in the 1980s, a view emerged stating that not everything from the past could and should be saved. This is also related to the emergence of awareness that a heritage building can have significance after going through development, modification, and use for quite a long period (Kwanda, 2013).…”

Section: Conservation Principlesmentioning

confidence: 99%

Conservation Principles and Infill Design Analysis of De Mier Eat and Stay Surabaya

Santoso¹,

Kwanda²

2023

atrium j. ars

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Darmo is an area in the city of Surabaya which rich in architecture from the Dutch colonial period. Based on the Regional Regulations of the City of Surabaya, not all buildings in the Darmo area are protected. A lot of the original buildings were being interfered with. De Mier Eat and Stay is an example of adaptive reuse in the Darmo area that collaborates preserved Dutch Indies-styled building with a new modern building to accommodate new functions. This paper examines how successful conservation and infill design principles are applied in De Mier Eat and Stay. The research method was conducted qualitatively through site visits and interviews with the designer. The data were then analyzed with a comparative table based on the literature. From this study, it can be concluded that the interventions done in the opening elements fulfill all four conservation principles. In contrast, the wall elements only fulfill three, and the floor elements didn’t fulfill at all. The Infill design was done using the contrast approach. Collaborating two eras of architecture through façade, proportion, materials, and the responses to surroundings creates a unique harmony in De Mier Eat and Stay.

show abstract

The role of attributes defining intervention concepts in international doctrinal documents on built heritage

Lin,

Nevzgodin,

Pereira Roders

et al. 2023

JCHMSD

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

PurposeAttributes conveying cultural significance play a key role in heritage management, as well as in differentiating interventions in built heritage. However, seldom the relation between interventions and attributes, either tangible or intangible, has been researched systematically. How do both tangible and intangible attributes and interventions relate? What attributes make interventions on built heritage differ?Design/methodology/approachThis paper conducts a systematic content analysis of forty-one international doctrinal documents—mainly adopted by the Council of Europe, UNESCO and ICOMOS, between 1877 and 2021. The main aim is to reveal and compare the selected eight intervention concepts, namely—restoration (C1), preservation (C2), conservation (C3), adaptation (C4), rehabilitation (C5), relocation (C6), reconstruction (C7) and renewal (C8)—and their definitions, in relation to attributes, both tangible and intangible. The intensity of the relationship between intervention concepts and attributes is determined based on the frequency of the mentioned attributes per intervention.FindingsThere were three key findings. First, although the attention to intangible attributes has increased in the last decades, the relationship between interventions and tangible attributes remains stronger. The highest frequency of referencing the tangible attributes was identified in “relocation” and “preservation,” while the lowest was in “rehabilitation.” Second, certain attributes play contradictory roles, e.g. “material,” “use” and “process,” which creates inconsistent definitions between documents. Third, as attributes often include one another in building layers, they trigger the intervention concepts in hierarchical patterns.Originality/valueThis paper explores and discusses the results of a novel comparative analysis between different intervention concepts and definitions, with a particular focus on the attributes. The results can support further research and practice, clarifying the identified differences and similarities.

show abstract

Western Conservation Theory and the Asian Context: The Different Roots of Conservation

Abstract: secondary data from journals and books

Cited by 5 publications

References 4 publications

Multi-sensori dalam konsepsi tempat pada lingkungan cagar budaya perkotaan

Multi-sensori dalam konsepsi tempat pada lingkungan cagar budaya perkotaan

Conservation Principles and Infill Design Analysis of De Mier Eat and Stay Surabaya

The role of attributes defining intervention concepts in international doctrinal documents on built heritage

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About