Wastewater Discharge and Reuse Regulation in Costa Rica: An Opportunity for Improvement

Abstract

A database was built with the results of the physicochemical analysis of 23,435 samples of wastewater discharges obtained from the operational reports presented and the cross-checks carried out by the Ministry of Health to the operating entities, in accordance with the provisions of Decree 30661-MINAE-S, for the period 2016–2020. Using Bayesian networks, the probabilities of compliance with current regulations were estimated by preparing an acyclic directed graph for three alternative scenarios. At the national level, the BOD and the COD are the variables that record the lowest values, showing important differences between the results obtained for the central region of the country with respect to the other regions. Another determining variable turned out to be the type of final disposal, wherein the reuse of wastewater presents important compliance deficiencies for all regions except for Chorotega. In the case of BOD, COD and TSS, the lowest probabilities are recorded for ISIC codes 3821 (treatment of non-hazardous waste), 1040 (manufacture of animal and vegetable fats) and 145 (pig farming). Additionally, the integrated environmental risk was calculated as a product of the discharges, obtaining that for the evaluated parameters, the BOD and COD represent the highest risk values given their probability of occurrence rate, as well as the magnitude of the environmental impact. The Pacifico Central and Brunca regions recorded the highest integrated environmental risk value for BOD, COD and TSS compared to the other areas of the country. Based on the results obtained, proposals for improvement were generated for the control of wastewater discharges carried out by the environmental authorities in search of achieving a better comprehensive management of the water resource.

On Sustainable Consumption: The Implications of Trade in Virtual Water for the EU’s Food Security

“…Some studies are specific about the remedies that are most needed to overcome the mishandling of sustainability goals. These are related, for example, to water management in Colombia (Torres et al (2020) [72]), wastewater discharges in Costa Rica (Herrera-Murillo et al (2021) [73]), employee training in Ecuador (Ramírez-Orellana et al (2021) [74]), and producers' certifications in Ghana and Cote d'Ivoire (Ingram et al (2018) [75]). The interest in RSPO and ISPO certification in Malaysia for palm oil producers and the need for government involvement in addressing sustainable production are also reflected in Azis et al (2021) [76] and Majid et al (2021) [77], whereas Nurfatriani et al (2019) [78] strengthened the need for sustainability-related certification in Indonesia (see our results in Table S4, Supplementary Materials).…”

Monitoring the risk ofLegionellainfection using a general Bayesian network updated from temporal measurements in agricultural irrigation with reclaimed wastewater

“…42 BNs can be applied to a wide range of application domains such as environmental modelling 43 and artificial intelligence, 44 and as mentioned above to quantitative microbial risk assessment (for a review, see Beaudequin et al (2015) 45 ), and water reuse and QMRA. 41,42,[46][47][48] While QMRAs are often constrained by the availability of required data (for example, in dose-response assessments), system models based on BNs are an effective framework that tackle the lack of data. As all data in the network contribute to the whole, accurate predictions can be made with incomplete data or a quite small sample size.…”

Decision Making Model for Municipal Wastewater Conventional Secondary Treatment with Bayesian Networks

“…They showed that both quantitative (such as water quality and land use data) and qualitative variables (different seasonal scenarios) can be incorporated into a model. Through the design of a Bayesian network, Herrera-Murillo et al [32] estimated the probabilities of complying with regulations in wastewater discharges under some alternative scenarios of operation.…”