“Walking wounded or wounded healer?” Does personal experience of mental health problems help or hinder mental health practice? A review of the literature

Abstract

Purpose – A systematic review of the literature on “wounded healers” was undertaken to identify, define and interpret the term and its application within the mental health environment. The paper aims to discuss these issues. Design/methodology/approach – Eight key medical/social sciences databases were interrogated. In total, 835 papers were identified in the systematic database search and abstracts were obtained for each to determine whether they met the inclusion criteria. In total, 237 sources were retrieved for critical reading, to assess relevance and value to the review, and 125 documents were subsequently included. Through thematic analysis a number of themes and sub themes were identified Findings – The archetypal image of the wounded healer originates in ancient mythology and crosses many cultures. There are many interpretations and applications of the belief that having healed their own wounds a person is in a better position to heal others, however, the evidence to support this is not so robust. Of more direct relevance to contemporary practice are reports of supporting staff with mental health problems to make a contribution to mental health services, most recently through the employment of peer support workers. Originality/value – As peer support workers are increasingly being employed in mental health services, it is helpful to consider the many existing staff who bring personal experience of mental health problems. This paper explores the evidence that their lived experience makes a difference to the way that they work and considers their employment support needs.

‘Your experiences were your tools’. How personal experience of mental health problems informs mental health nursing practice

“…Perhaps surprisingly, the ‘wounded healer’ image was not referred to by the participants, although they did say that their experiences had motivated them to nurse and gave them enhanced understanding and credibility. Whilst the image has stayed pertinent in the theoretical and autobiographical literature on the helping professions, as evidenced by Conchar & Repper's () review, it is not used by mental health nurses about themselves. A revised conceptualization of mental health professionals with mental ill health is needed, whereby experience of mental ill health is contextualized, both by the other personal influences on the professionals’ working practice and by the situations and relationships where personal experience is overtly drawn on or disclosed.…”

“…When the impact of a person's own mental ill health on mental health work has been examined in previous studies, common images are either of the ‘impaired professional’ or the ‘wounded healer’. Where the ‘wounded healer’ is an archetypal image of a helper whose own experiences give them curative powers and motivate them to heal others (MacCulloch & Shattell , Zerubavel & Wright , Conchar & Repper ), ‘impaired professionals’ are perceived as presenting potential risk to service users and clients (Telepak ). They draw negatively on their experiences, adversely affecting engagement and causing stigma and censure from their colleagues and managers (Telepak ).…”

Barriers, facilitators, and survival strategies for GPs seeking treatment for distress: a qualitative study

“…29 These findings add depth to this information around 'presenteeism', by showing the degree of guilt associated with the pressure to stay at work that can drive this unhealthy practice. Participants also confirm the continued perceived stigma around mental illness.…”

Trauma-Informed Self-Care for Child and Youth Care Workers

“…Terr (1991) noted two sorts of trauma: type one, which involves a single incident, and type two, which involves multiple traumas over an extended period. However, in passing it must be noted that some trauma survivors acknowledge that often from trauma arises personal growth and resilience or hardiness, which is the so-called salutogenic effect (Conchar & Repper, 2014).…”