Wages and the Value of Nonemployment

Abstract

Nonemployment is often posited as a worker's outside option in wage setting models such as bargaining and wage posting. The value of this state is therefore a fundamental determinant of wages and, in turn, labor supply and job creation. We measure the effect of changes in the value of nonemployment on wages in existing jobs and among job switchers. Our quasi-experimental variation in nonemployment values arises from four large reforms of unemployment insurance (UI) benefit levels in Austria. We document that wages are insensitive to UI benefit levels: point estimates imply a wage response of less than $0.01 per $1.00 UI benefit increase, and we can reject sensitivities larger than 0.03. In contrast, a calibrated Nash bargaining model predicts a sensitivity of 0.39-more than ten times larger. The empirical insensitivity holds even among workers with a priori low bargaining power, with low labor force attachment, with high predicted unemployment duration, among job switchers and recently unemployed workers, in areas of high unemployment, in firms with flexible pay policies, and when considering firm-level bargaining. The insensitivity of wages to the nonemployment value we document presents a puzzle to widely used wage setting protocols, and implies that nonemployment may not constitute workers' relevant threat point. Our evidence supports wage-setting mechanisms that insulate wages from the value of nonemployment.

Wage Setting Behaviour of Firms in Industrial Estates of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan

“…It is supported by the prominent theories of unemployment, i.e. efficiency wage model and insider-outsider models (Jager, Schoefer, Young, & Zweimüller, 2020).…”

Supply and Demand Effects of Unemployment Insurance Benefit Extensions: Evidence from U.S. Counties

“…In principle, the increase in employment and labor force could also be due to migration, as workers from other counties may move to counties that grow faster due to the local stimulus. 21 However, column (iii) shows that this effect is small and less statistically significant: labor force growth in one county does not appear to come at the expense of labor force growth in other counties.…”

“…In addition to the literature on local fiscal multipliers, the paper also contributes directly to a growing literature on the labor market implications of UI benefit generosity. While some recent microeconomic studies find no effect of benefit generosity on unemployed workers' willingness to accept a job (Krueger and Mueller, 2016;Jaeger et al, 2020), others provide evidence that extending the UI benefit duration leads to reduced job search effort (Card, Chetty, Marinescu, 2017), though the effect declines in recessions (Schmieder et al, 2012;Kroft and Notowidigdo, 2016). At the macro level, the literature has focused on whether changes in individual search behavior in response to more generous UI policies translate into higher unemployment rates.…”

Dying to Work: Effects of Unemployment Insurance on Health

“…For example, exploit changes in UI benefit levels in Austria in the 1980s and 1990s and find that wages are relatively unresponsive to UI generosity. This insensitivity holds even among low-wage earners, frequent job switchers, and those with high predicted unemployment duration (Jäger, Schoefer, Young, and Zweimüller, 2019). characteristics but vary by UI duration eligiblity, these data allow us to improve on existing work and get a better sense of how UI duration affects an individual's physical and mental health.…”