Vulnerable Voices: An examination of the concept of vulnerability in relation to student voice

Abstract

Vulnerable student voices are a matter for concern in contemporary higher education, but that concern is directed more towards identifying vulnerable groups, and seeking to widen their participation in higher education. It is less to do with the vulnerability of certain modes of voice when students are there.The concept of student voice may be anatomised into three constituent elements: an epistemological voice, or a voice for knowing, a practical voice, or a voice for doing, and an ontological voice, or a voice for being and becoming. A voice for being and becoming is less valued and validated in contemporary higher education, and more vulnerable, than voices for knowing and doing. Developing an ontological voice is deemed less important than developing epistemological or practical voices, yet an ontological voice is fundamental to those two other voices.The concept of vulnerability needs to be extended from referring to certain underrepresented groups in the student body to indicating the strength or weakness of certain modes of the student voice. Vulnerability is not only about the vulnerability of the presenting student, but also about his voice yet to be uncovered. Reinterpreting vulnerability fosters modes of recovering ontological voices at risk of being lost.

Conceptualizing feedback literacy: knowing, being, and acting

“…This said, Batchelor (2006) wants to challenge the negative view of learner vulnerability as weakness and dependence and embrace a positive postmodern view of the self. From this perspective vulnerability connotes epistemological and ontological flexibility and openness.…”

Voices from the classroom: Pre-service teachers’ interactions with supervising teachers

“…Forty finalyear Bachelor of Education students at the University of the Witwatersrand gave their consent to participate in a qualitative study using open-ended questionnaires. This research aimed to explore pre-service teachers ' voices, using Denise Batchelor's (2008;2006) research pertaining to conceptualisations of voice, namely, practical, epistemological and ontological, which were used to analyse the data. The findings suggested that pre-service teachers' pedagogical choices were linked to the supervising teachers' guidance.…”

Vulnerability and risk in children living with a physical disability

“…However, this view is problematic when vulnerability is associated with disability in such a manner that disabilities are equated with weakness, inferiority and dependence on other, stronger people (Batchelor 2006, Willetts 2010.…”