Vocabularies and Retrieval Tools in Biomedicine: Disentangling the Terminological Knot

Abstract

Terms like "thesaurus", "taxonomy", "classification", "glossary", "ontology" and "controlled vocabulary" can be used in diverse contexts, causing confusion and vagueness about their denotation. Is a thesaurus a tool to enrich a writer's style or an indexing tool used in bibliographic retrieval? Or can it be both? A literature study was to clear the confusion, but rather than giving us consensus definitions, it provided us with conflicting descriptions. We classified these definitions into three domains: linguistics, knowledge management and bibliographic retrieval. The scope of the terms is therefore highly dependent on the context. We propose one definition per term, per context. In addition to this intra-conceptual confusion, there is also inter-conceptual vagueness. This leads to the introduction of misnomers, like "ontology" in the Gene Ontology. We examined some important (bio)medical systems for their compatibility with the definitions proposed in the first part of this paper. To conclude, an overview of these systems and their classification into the three domains is given.

Reporting Observational Studies of the Use of Information Technology in the Clinical Consultation

“…We developed a "faceted classif ication" to bring together the components that we concluded were an important part of reporting these studies. The main advantage of a faceted classification is that it offers considerable flexibility; this is because facets can be ordered in different ways rather than requiring a single taxonomic order [22]. A faceted classification can thus include: 1.…”

Lists, Taxonomies, Lattices, Thesauri and Ontologies: Paving a Pathway Through a Terminological Jungle

“…In AI applications dealing with natural language processing and machine translation, the term lexicon is used to refer to a machine-readable entity containing the lexical information required to support syntactic and morphological processing. It may therefore incorporate lexical elements and language rules (Vanopstal et al 2009). The lexical elements can either be in full forms or canonical base forms, while the language rules appear in the form of parts of speech facts, spelling and grammar rules, and morphologi-cal rules for creating new words.…”

Empowering industrial research with shared biomedical vocabularies

“…Here, we use the word 'vocabulary' to refer to a terminological resource that provides the identification and definition of entities (also known as 'concepts') within a scientific domain. This includes taxonomies, ontologies and terminologies as defined by Smith et al [35] and glossaries, dictionaries, lexicons, thesauri, taxonomies and ontologies as defined by Vanopstal et al [36]. Each of these vocabulary forms fit with different use cases and applications, but all provide an ability to unambiguously identify biomedical entities.…”