Viral RNA Degradation Makes Urine a Challenging Specimen for Detection of Japanese Encephalitis Virus in Patients With Suspected CNS Infection

Abstract

Background Japanese encephalitis virus (JEV) is a leading cause of central nervous system (CNS) infections in Asia and results in significant morbidity and mortality. JEV RNA is rarely detected in serum or cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), and diagnosis of JEV infection is usually based on serological tests that are frequently difficult to interpret. Unlike serum or CSF, urine is relatively easy to obtain, but, to date, there has been minimal work on the feasibility of testing urine for JEV RNA. Methods We investigated the use of lysis buffer and a Microsep device to optimize urine storage for detection of JEV RNA by reverse transcription real-time polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR). The best of the studied methods was then evaluated in consecutive patients admitted to the hospital with suspected CNS infections in Laos. Results We demonstrated degradation of JEV RNA in urine after even short storage periods at 4°C or –80°C. Although there was no advantage in using a Microsep concentration device alone, immediate addition of lysis buffer to fresh urine improved the detection of JEV RNA at the limit of detection. Conclusions In 2 studies of 41 patients with acute encephalitis syndrome, 11 (27%) were positive for JEV IgM in CSF and/or serum, and 2 (4.9%) were JEV RT-qPCR positive from throat swabs. JEV RNA was not detected in any of these patients’ urine samples. However, lysis buffer was only used during a prospective study, that is, for only 17/41 (41%) patient urine samples. Our findings suggest a need for larger studies testing urine for JEV RNA, with urine collected at different times from symptom onset, and using lysis buffer, which stabilizes RNA, for storage.

Diagnostic and methodological evaluation of studies on the urinary shedding of SARS-CoV-2, compared to stool and serum: A systematic review and meta-analysis

“…Real-time RT-PCR Ct (cycle threshold) values may also differ because of specimen collection or handling. The presence of several enzymes such as protease, RNase, or bacteria and the absence of proteins that stabilize RNA and virus in the urine may explain the quick degradation of viral RNA (78,79). Technical improvement in the sampling to prevent degradation of the urinary viral RNA (such as immediate addition of lysis buffer to the fresh urine) may help to increase the diagnostic sensitivity and diminish false negative (78,80).…”

Urinary genome detection and tracking of Hantaan virus from hemorrhagic fever with renal syndrome patients using multiplex PCR-based next-generation sequencing

“…In addition, the urine of humans is a suitable environment for nucleic acid hydrolyzing enzymes caused by various ion concentrations and proper pH (from 5.0 to 7.0) [ 28 ]. Nucleic acid stabilizers (e.g., Buffer ATL, DNA/RNA Shield) improved the recovery of ZIKV, DENV, Venezuelan equine encephalitis virus, and Rift Valley fever virus RNA, particularly at low viral titers [ 29 – 32 ]. However, the stability of HTNV RNA in urine has not been reported yet.…”

Japanese encephalitis virus: changing the clinical landscape of encephalitis in Australia

“…When CSF PCR is positive, this is usually early in the course of illness 2 . Prolonged shedding in urine has been described in one case study, 15 and it is theorised that the prompt addition of lysis buffer to urine might prevent RNA degradation in this sample type 16 . One study has demonstrated the potential for detection via PCR on throat swab 17 and, given the low invasiveness of this sample method and the potential for increasing diagnostic yield before seroconversion, this may be considered.…”