Ventilation rates in California classrooms: Why many recent HVAC retrofits are not delivering sufficient ventilation

Abstract

Previous research has shown that under-ventilation of classrooms is common and negatively impacts student health and learning. To advance understanding of contributing factors, this study visited 104 classrooms from 11 schools that had recently been retrofitted with new heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning (HVAC) units. CO2 concentration, room and supply air temperature and relative humidity, and door opening were measured for four weeks in each classroom. Field inspections identified HVAC equipment, fan control, and/or filter maintenance problems in 51% of the studied classrooms. Across 94 classrooms with valid data, average CO2 concentrations measured during school hours had a mean of 895 ppm and a standard deviation (SD) of 263 ppm. Ventilation rates (VRs), estimated using the daily maximum 15-minute CO2 in each classroom, had a mean of 5.2 L/s-person and a SD of 2.0 L/s-person across 94 classrooms. Classrooms with economizers, with or without demand control ventilation (DCV), tended to have lower mean CO2. Improperly selected equipment, lack of commissioning, incorrect fan control settings and maintenance issues (heavily loaded filters) were all associated with underventilation in classrooms. Many classrooms in this sample were frequently too warm to support learning. There were 23 out of 103 classrooms that had indoor air temperature above 25.6 o C for more than 20% of the school hours. Better oversight on HVAC system installation and commissioning are needed to ensure adequate classroom ventilation. Periodic testing of ventilation systems and/or continuous real-time CO2 monitoring (either as stand-alone monitors or incorporated into thermostats) is recommended to detect and correct ventilation problems.

Health effects of wildfire smoke in children and public health tools: a narrative review

“…A review of the literature summarized studies in classrooms across North America, Europe, and Asia and found widespread evidence of inadequate ventilation [116]. Notably, many classrooms with recently retrofitted HVAC systems still had inadequate ventilation (especially those with wall-mounted units), often related to filters needing to be changed, disuse of the fan during the time the classroom was in use, or improper installation [117].…”

Effects of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Indoor Air Quality and Thermal Comfort of Primary Schools in Winter in a Mediterranean Climate

“…Conditions of vulnerability are especially pronounced in pre-schools and primary schools [45,46], due to the age of the potential students: 4 to 6 years of age in the former and 6 to 12 in the latter. Avoiding crowded, poorly ventilated classrooms is a requirement for the safe and healthy return of most pupils to school [29,47]. The implementation of a system of hygrothermal conditions and IAQ monitoring (air temperature (ta), RH, CO 2 ), together with other interventions, is conditional on the success of not exceeding acceptable limits [24].…”

On Implementation of Plants in the Indoor Environment in Intelligent Buildings

“…The generally recommended maximum CO 2 concentration is 1000 ppm (Torpy et al, 2017;Lu et al, 2015;Tsai et al, 2012;Seppanen et al, 1999). Higher concentrations can have a negative effect on the people's performance in the indoor environment of buildings (Satish et al, 2012;Allen et al, 2016;Pinto et al, 2021;Chan et al, 2020). The sick building syndrome can appear in places with long-term occurrence in environments with higher concentrations of CO 2 .…”